Written by Jillian Collins
Australian Privacy Commissioner Karen Curtis has concluded her investigation into Google's collection of unsecured WiFi payload data in Australia using Street View vehicles and finds that such collection violated Australian law.
"On the information available I am satisfied that any collection of personal information would have breached the Australian Privacy Act,” she said. "Collecting personal information in these circumstances is a very serious matter. Australians should reasonably expect that private communications remain private.”
For its part, Google has promised to publish an apology to Australians for its collection of unsecured WiFi 'payload' data. Google will also conduct a Privacy Impact Assessment (PIA) on any new Street View data collection activities in Australia that include personal information and regularly consult with the Australian Privacy Commissioner about personal data collection activities arising from significant product launches in Australia.
The apology, posted on the official Google Australia blog, states in part:
“To be clear, we did not want and have never used any payload data in our products or services--and as soon as we discovered our error, we announced that we would stop collecting all WiFi data via our Street View vehicles and removed all WiFi reception equipment from them…
We want to reiterate to Australians that this was a mistake for which we are sincerely sorry. Maintaining people's trust is crucial to everything we do and we have to earn that trust every single day. We are acutely aware that we failed badly here.”
Google admitted in May that it had collected certain WiFi content information--known as "payload data"--in some 33 countries, including in Australia, with special equipment mounted on its Street View photographic image collection vehicles.
Google may not get away so easily in other countries for the privacy breach. German authorities are leading an investigation that may result in criminal penalties, there is a class-action lawsuit against the company in the U.S., and Federal Trade Commission has said it will "a very close look" at the company's behavior. In some other countries, including Britain, Germany, France, and Italy, authorities have demanded that Google hand over the payload data so that it can be used in possible legal cases against the company.
Related Links:
http://www.businessweek.com/technology/content/jul2010/tc2010079_071459.htm
http://www.smh.com.au/technology/technology-news/google-wifi-snooping-broke-the-law-privacy-watchdog-20100709-103eh.html
Google’s apology: http://google-au.blogspot.com/2010/07/were-sorry.html
Statement from the Australian Privacy Commissioner: http://www.privacy.gov.au/materials/a-z?fullsummary=7103
Showing posts with label Google. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Google. Show all posts
Tuesday, July 13, 2010
Tuesday, June 22, 2010
The Google Payload Data Fallout Continues
Written by Jillian Collins
Connecticut Attorney General Richard Blumenthal says he will lead a multistate investigation into Google Street View cars’ unauthorized collection of personal data from WiFi networks. The Connecticut AG said he expects a significant number of states to participate. More than 30 states participated in a recent conference call regarding the Connecticut investigation.
In a statement released yesterday, Blumenthal called Google’s data collection a “deeply disturbing invasion of personal privacy,” and said that consumers have a right to know what personal information, including potentially emails, web browsing habits and passwords, Google may have collected. “Google must come clean, explaining how and why it intercepted and saved private information broadcast over personal and business wireless networks,” he said. Google maintains that it did not collect the payload data intentionally and never used it , but the company may be facing not only domestic consequences but also investigations in the UK and other affected countries. Google says it stopped collecting Wi-Fi data from its Street View vehicles when it discovered the data collection problem last month following an inquiry by German regulators. The Google payload data incident is just one recent PR problem related to privacy concerns for the internet giant. Google took harsh criticism for the launch of Buzz because the feature initially revealed information about the names of users' email contacts. Google has significantly revised the service; now, it merely suggests followers, rather than automatically creating them.
Related links:http://www.mediapost.com/publications/?fa=Articles.showArticle&art_aid=130619http://www.foxnews.com/world/2010/06/22/uk-police-investigating-alleged-google-privacy-breach-public-wi-fi-networks/
Connecticut Attorney General Richard Blumenthal says he will lead a multistate investigation into Google Street View cars’ unauthorized collection of personal data from WiFi networks. The Connecticut AG said he expects a significant number of states to participate. More than 30 states participated in a recent conference call regarding the Connecticut investigation.
In a statement released yesterday, Blumenthal called Google’s data collection a “deeply disturbing invasion of personal privacy,” and said that consumers have a right to know what personal information, including potentially emails, web browsing habits and passwords, Google may have collected. “Google must come clean, explaining how and why it intercepted and saved private information broadcast over personal and business wireless networks,” he said. Google maintains that it did not collect the payload data intentionally and never used it , but the company may be facing not only domestic consequences but also investigations in the UK and other affected countries. Google says it stopped collecting Wi-Fi data from its Street View vehicles when it discovered the data collection problem last month following an inquiry by German regulators. The Google payload data incident is just one recent PR problem related to privacy concerns for the internet giant. Google took harsh criticism for the launch of Buzz because the feature initially revealed information about the names of users' email contacts. Google has significantly revised the service; now, it merely suggests followers, rather than automatically creating them.
Related links:http://www.mediapost.com/publications/?fa=Articles.showArticle&art_aid=130619http://www.foxnews.com/world/2010/06/22/uk-police-investigating-alleged-google-privacy-breach-public-wi-fi-networks/
Wednesday, May 26, 2010
Congressmen Question Google on Wi-Fi
Today, Congressmen Joe Barton (R-TX), Edward Markey (D-MA), and Henry Waxman (D-CA)wrote to Google Chairman and CEO Eric Schmidt seeking answers to the company’s collection of private information over Wi-Fi networks.
“We are concerned that Google did not disclose until long after the fact that consumers’ Internet use was being recorded, analyzed and perhaps profiled. In addition, we are concerned about the completeness and accuracy of Google’s public explanations about this matter,” wrote the lawmakers. “For example, on April 27, 2010, a Google blog post contained inaccurate information about whether payload data was collected. However, a Google executive on May 14, 2010, admitted in Google’s official blog that the company had ‘been mistakenly collecting samples of payload data from open (i.e., non-password-protected) Wi-Fi networks.’”
Barton and Markey, co-chairmen of the House Privacy Caucus, separately wrote last week to Federal Trade Commission Chairman Jon Liebowitz about Google’s recent revelation that it gathered the network information.
The lawmakers asked Schmidt to respond to the following questions:
What percentage of United States roads have been documented for Google Street View?
Over what time period did the collection of information for Google Street View take place or, if roads are visited by Google Street View vehicles more than once, what is the schedule for return visits to roads?
Have all Street View vehicles documenting United States roads been engaged in the monitoring or data collection of Wi-Fi transmissions at all times during those activities? If the answer is no, please explain in detail in what communities the monitoring or data collection was conducted and the reasons that these communities were chosen for monitoring or data collection.
How many Wi-Fi networks across the country have been logged since Google began its Street View program? How many consumers were subject to the data collection?
Was any notification of this monitoring and data collection made to affected communities prior to deploying Street View vehicles, and was consent sought from consumers? If so, please explain the notice and consent procedures involved. If not, please explain why this was not done.
Has Google at any time conducted a legal analysis regarding the applicability of consumer privacy laws on the monitoring and data collection of Wi-Fi transmissions? If so, please provide a copy of this analysis.
Please explain why Google chose to collect the data and how it intended to use the data.
What is the status of the consumer data collected? Has it been analyzed and used in any way? Does Google have plans to use it in the future? Please explain in detail.
Has the collected data been destroyed? If yes, when and by which method(s)? If not, why not?
What is the status of Google’s internal review of Street View’s monitoring and data collection practices to ensure adequate controls? What is the methodology? When did the review start? Who is conducting the review? Are there any interim findings? When is it expected to be completed? Will the review, or portions of it, be made available to the public?
What is Google’s process to ensure that data collection associated with new products and services offered by the company is adequately controlled?
Has Google asked a third party to review the software at issue? If so, who is the third party, and what is the nature of the review?
A copy of the letter to Schmidt can be found here. A copy of the letter to the FTC on the Google can be found here.
“We are concerned that Google did not disclose until long after the fact that consumers’ Internet use was being recorded, analyzed and perhaps profiled. In addition, we are concerned about the completeness and accuracy of Google’s public explanations about this matter,” wrote the lawmakers. “For example, on April 27, 2010, a Google blog post contained inaccurate information about whether payload data was collected. However, a Google executive on May 14, 2010, admitted in Google’s official blog that the company had ‘been mistakenly collecting samples of payload data from open (i.e., non-password-protected) Wi-Fi networks.’”
Barton and Markey, co-chairmen of the House Privacy Caucus, separately wrote last week to Federal Trade Commission Chairman Jon Liebowitz about Google’s recent revelation that it gathered the network information.
The lawmakers asked Schmidt to respond to the following questions:
What percentage of United States roads have been documented for Google Street View?
Over what time period did the collection of information for Google Street View take place or, if roads are visited by Google Street View vehicles more than once, what is the schedule for return visits to roads?
Have all Street View vehicles documenting United States roads been engaged in the monitoring or data collection of Wi-Fi transmissions at all times during those activities? If the answer is no, please explain in detail in what communities the monitoring or data collection was conducted and the reasons that these communities were chosen for monitoring or data collection.
How many Wi-Fi networks across the country have been logged since Google began its Street View program? How many consumers were subject to the data collection?
Was any notification of this monitoring and data collection made to affected communities prior to deploying Street View vehicles, and was consent sought from consumers? If so, please explain the notice and consent procedures involved. If not, please explain why this was not done.
Has Google at any time conducted a legal analysis regarding the applicability of consumer privacy laws on the monitoring and data collection of Wi-Fi transmissions? If so, please provide a copy of this analysis.
Please explain why Google chose to collect the data and how it intended to use the data.
What is the status of the consumer data collected? Has it been analyzed and used in any way? Does Google have plans to use it in the future? Please explain in detail.
Has the collected data been destroyed? If yes, when and by which method(s)? If not, why not?
What is the status of Google’s internal review of Street View’s monitoring and data collection practices to ensure adequate controls? What is the methodology? When did the review start? Who is conducting the review? Are there any interim findings? When is it expected to be completed? Will the review, or portions of it, be made available to the public?
What is Google’s process to ensure that data collection associated with new products and services offered by the company is adequately controlled?
Has Google asked a third party to review the software at issue? If so, who is the third party, and what is the nature of the review?
A copy of the letter to Schmidt can be found here. A copy of the letter to the FTC on the Google can be found here.
Thursday, February 25, 2010
“Stunning”/ “Shear Madness” – Reaction to Google Convictions
The reactions are coming in fast and furious to yesterday’s conviction of three Google executives in an Italian court. Linked here are just a few of the more than 1,000 media stories on the decision so far.
Google privacy convictions in Italy spark outrage
Larger Threat Is Seen in Google Case - NYTimes.com
Conviction of Google Execs in Italy Shear Madness
Kerry: Sending Google execs to prison 'unjust' - The Hill's Hillicon Valley
Google privacy convictions in Italy spark outrage
Larger Threat Is Seen in Google Case - NYTimes.com
Conviction of Google Execs in Italy Shear Madness
Kerry: Sending Google execs to prison 'unjust' - The Hill's Hillicon Valley
Wednesday, February 24, 2010
BREAKING NEWS: Google Executives Convicted on Privacy Charges in Italy
In the first case of its kind, an Italian judge today convicted three Google executives on privacy violations in Milan court. Global Privacy Counsel Peter Fleischer, Chief Legal Officer David Drummond, and another executive were found guilty of failing to comply with Italian privacy code in allowing a disparaging video to be posted online. A fourth defendant was acquitted. All three will appeal the decision.
Judge Oscar Magi ordered a six-month suspended jail sentence and fines for Fleischer, Drummond and former Google Italy board member George De Los Reyes. The three were absolved of defamation charges. .The case stems from the posting of a video to Google Video Italia showing teenage boys taunting a classmate with Down syndrome. Prosecutors charged that the executives did not do enough to keep the offensive video off its site. In a statement, Peter Fleischer said the ruling sets a dangerous precedent. “If company employees like me can be held criminally liable for any video on a hosting platform…then our liability is unlimited.” He said today’s decision raises questions for the operators of many Internet platforms.
Stay tuned.
Judge Oscar Magi ordered a six-month suspended jail sentence and fines for Fleischer, Drummond and former Google Italy board member George De Los Reyes. The three were absolved of defamation charges. .The case stems from the posting of a video to Google Video Italia showing teenage boys taunting a classmate with Down syndrome. Prosecutors charged that the executives did not do enough to keep the offensive video off its site. In a statement, Peter Fleischer said the ruling sets a dangerous precedent. “If company employees like me can be held criminally liable for any video on a hosting platform…then our liability is unlimited.” He said today’s decision raises questions for the operators of many Internet platforms.
Stay tuned.
Thursday, July 9, 2009
Google on Trial in Italy
Friends at the Norton Rose law firm have published a great Update on Google Italian prosecution. The trial of the Google executives has been delayed, but the Norton Rose piece outlines the background of the proceedings and the current status.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)