Showing posts with label identity theft. Show all posts
Showing posts with label identity theft. Show all posts

Monday, May 24, 2010

Red Flags Rule Compliance Date Approaching - American Medical Association Sues

It’s been a while since we have visited the Federal Trade Commission’s Red Flags Rule here in this blog. The oft-postponed deadline is now fast approaching on June 1. Except, that is, for lawyers and now, doctors.

On Friday, the American Medical Association filed a lawsuit against the FTC for defining physicians as “creditors” and claiming that requiring physicians to comply with the Red Flags Rule could jeopardize the doctor-patient confidential relationship. The Red Flags Rule (to refresh your memory) requires that “creditors” establish identity theft protection programs and would likely require physicians to obtain positive identification of patient identity – before providing treatment, as argued by the AMA.

The lawsuit argues that the FTC acted beyond its authority because physicians are not creditors and patients are neither accountholders nor customers under the Fair and Accurate Credit Transactions Act (FACTA). The latter is a more likely argument than the former. Under FACTA, an “entity that regularly defers payment for goods or services” can be considered to be a creditor and physicians routinely bill patients after the completion of services, including for the remainder of medical fees not reimbursed by insurance. I have been in doctor’s offices over the last 6 months where new patients are asked for their insurance card, and their driver’s license or a photo ID. This would seem to be a small step towards controlling medical identity theft.

Read about medical identity theft at World Privacy Forum Medical Identity Theft Page

Tuesday, March 9, 2010

Breaking News - ID Theft Company to Pay $12 Million for Deceptive Advertising

“[E]nough holes that you could drive a truck through it…..”

That’s how Federal Trade Commission Chairman Jon Leibowitz described the identity theft protection offered to consumers by the widely-advertised LifeLock product and the claims made by the company that its service provided comprehensive identity theft protection. Those claims have cost the company $12 million dollars in a settlement announced today by the FTC chairman and Illinois Attorney General Lisa Madigan. According to the lawsuit, LifeLock claimed its service would protect consumers against all forms of identity theft, when, in fact, LifeLock offered only limited protection against only some forms of identity theft and had no effect on the most common form: the misuse of existing credit card and bank accounts.

The settlement was announced at a press conference today and LifeLock has agreed to pay $11 million to the FTC and $1 million to a group of 25 state attorneys general to settle the deceptive advertising charges. In addition to the $12 million settlement, LifeLock and its co-founders Richard Todd Davis and Robert J. Maynard, Jr. are prohibited from making deceptive claims and required to better safeguard customers’ personal information.

The FTC will use the $11 million it receives from the settlements to provide refunds to consumers. It will be sending letters to the current and former customers of LifeLock who may be eligible for refunds under the settlement, along with instructions for applying.

Links
Complaint - Federal Trade Commission, Plaintiff, v. LifeLock, Inc., a corporation; Robert J. Maynard, Jr., individually and as an officer of LifeLock, Inc.; and Richard Todd Davis, individually and as an officer of LifeLock, Inc., Defendants

Press Release - Information on Lifelock Settlement

Thursday, January 28, 2010

Data Privacy Day - Tip #3 - The weakest link??

My lunchtime speaking engagement was at the International Association of Privacy Professional's Boston KnowledgeNet. I had the pleasure to share the panel with Mike Spinney from SixWeight (www.sixweight.com) and identity theft guru Robert Siciliano. We had a spirited discussion about privacy training and awareness. You can access their blogs in the panel to the right.

Our conclusion -- People are one of the weakest links in information security: employee negligence or wrongdoing is among the most common causes of security breaches.

Implement and train employees to follow formal information security policies that protect the private information of employees and customers.

Limit the number of people who have access to and/or handle confidential documents. Be careful when hiring new employees and perform full reference checks and, where warranted, ask new hires to sign confidentiality agreements.

Privacy awareness is as important as training and it should be continuing education.

Thursday, December 3, 2009

Court issues written opinion explaning decision regarding applicability of Red Flags Rule to attorneys

As we first blogged here, hours before the last Red Flags enforcement deadline, a federal court judge in the D.C. Circuit ruled from the bench that attorneys would not be subject to the Red Flags Rule. The court released Judge Walton's written opinion was released on December 1, 2009, which provides clarification of his comments from the bench. Click here for the opinion. Walton found the Federal Trade Commission overreached when it tried to define lawyers as "creditors". Walton wrote, "The Court is confident in concluding that the term attorney-client is nuanced enough that if Congress, which is comprised of many members who are themselves attorneys, intended to regulate attorneys and their invoiced billing practices it would have used the appropriate terminology to denote that intent and not hidden it in a statute expressly targeted at the credit industry." Judge Walton further noted, "Attorneys are already obligated to conduct themselves in a manner that promotes the objectives of the Red Flags Rule, and the Commission's position that its regulation is needed to protect third-parties against identity theft is just not the case."

On October 31, the FTC extended the Red Flags enforcement deadline for the fourth time to June 1, 2010.

Related Link:
Privacy and Security Information - Privacy MATTERS: Happy Halloween - No Red Flags Enforcement Until June 1, 2010.........

Friday, October 30, 2009

Happy Halloween - No Red Flags Enforcement Until June 1, 2010.........

Yet again, at the last minute, the Federal Trade Commission has announced that it is delaying enforcement of the Red Flags Rule. This time, the postponement is until June 1, 2010 and comes "[a]t the request of Congress."

This is the FOURTH time that the FTC has delayed "enforcement" of the controversial rules intended to detect and mitigate identity theft. It follows yesterday's federal court ruling that the Red Flags Rule does not apply to lawyers. It also follows on the heels of a 400-0 vote in favor of a House bill (H.R.3763) exempting certain small businesses from compliance with the Red Flags Rule.

As we have discussed in this blog on many occasions, the Red Flags Rule has been plagued with misunderstanding, controversy, and objections from the business community since its enactment in July of 2006. In the meantime, according to the FTC and other compilations of ID theft reports, nearly 25 million U.S. residents have reportedly been victims of identity theft. The regulatory effort is in danger of losing credibility.



Links:

Federal Trade Commission: www.ftc.gov/opa/2009/10/redflags.shtm
Privacy and Security MATTERS: www.privacyandsecuritymatters.blogspot.com/2009/10/changes-to-red-flag-rules-may-be-coming.html
Identity Theft Statistics: www.privacyrights.org/ar/idtheftsurveys

Wednesday, October 21, 2009

Changes to the "Red Flag" Rules may be coming -- and so is the November 1 compliance deadline

By an overwhelming vote of 400-0, the U.S. House yesterday approved legislation that will exempt certain businesses from the Federal Trade Commission’s Red Flag Rules. As we have reported, the Red Flag Rules require a broadly-defined class of “creditors” to implement identity theft prevention programs by November 1st. Under H.R. 3763, health care, accounting, and legal practices with 20 or fewer employees will be excluded from the definition of “creditor.” The measure also requires the FTC to issue new regulations allowing any business -- regardless of size -- to apply for an exemption.

New Exemption Provision
Under the exemption provision, the bill allows any business to be exempted if the FTC determines that the organization knows all of its customers or clients individually, only performs services in or around the residences of its customers, or has not experienced incidents of identity theft and is part of an industry that rarely experiences the problem. The FTC will be required to issue regulations setting out the exemption process.

ABA Still Not Happy

The American Bar Association says the legislation does not go far enough and
is demanding a full exemption for law firms. The ABA also continues
asking a federal court to bar the FTC from enforcing the rules against
attorneys. Besides the ABA, the FTC's broad interpretation of the creditor
category has prompted objections from the American Medical Association and the AICPA.
It is unlikely that this legislation will be finalized by the current November 1st enforcement deadline, and it remains to be seen whether this will cause the FTC to announce another delay.

Wednesday, September 2, 2009

Low Tech ID Theft ......

As Federal Reserve Chairman Ben Bernanke and his wife recently found out, identity theft often has nothing to do with technology….

PC Mag: Fed Chairman Hit by ID Theft