Written by Kevin McGinty
It’s a distressingly common scenario. A corporate laptop containing job applicant data, including social security numbers, is stolen from an employee who has taken the laptop off of corporate premises. Access to the social security numbers makes it possible for wrongdoers to engage in identity theft. Is an applicant’s fear that data will be misused enough to support claims for negligence and breach of contract against the company? The federal Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals has joined a growing number of courts in answering that question in the negative. In Ruiz v. Gap, Inc., the court held that California law requires actual damages to support claims for negligence and breach of contract, and that time and effort that the applicant allegedly expended to monitor for identity theft were insufficient to constitute actual damages. The court reached similar conclusions as to the claim under California’s consumer protection statute and, significantly, the claim for invasion of privacy. As to the latter, the court ruled that increased threat of a breach of privacy does not constitute an actual invasion of privacy.
None of this is to say that a company is immune from state law liability and can simply elect to do nothing when a data breach occurs. Although not detailed in the Ninth Circuit’s decision, The Gap took affirmative steps to protect applicants from potential harm arising from theft of their data. Not only did The Gap notify the applicants about the theft of the computer containing their personal information, but it also offered to provide twelve months of credit monitoring and fraud assistance without charge, plus $50,000 worth of identity theft insurance. The lesson of the Ruiz decision is that companies that do take reasonable steps to mitigate against potential misuse of stolen data will have a strong defense against further liability. It also reinforces the commonsense proposition that has bedeviled many attempts to parlay data breaches into class actions – the mere threat of bad consequences is not the same as actually suffering bad consequences. Thieves generally steal computers because they want the hardware, not the data. The loss of a computer containing personal data does not inevitably mean that such data will be misused. As such, claims arising from data breaches are unlikely to succeed unless there has also been identity theft and resulting adverse consequences for individuals whose identities have been stolen.
Showing posts with label privacy. Show all posts
Showing posts with label privacy. Show all posts
Monday, July 12, 2010
Thursday, June 24, 2010
Twitter Settles With FTC
Twitter has reached a settlement with the Federal Trade Commission (FTC) over charges that it “deceived consumers and put their privacy at risk by failing to safeguard their personal information.” In the Matter of Twitter, Inc.,
The FTC had alleged that “serious lapses” in Twitter’s security last year "allowed hackers to obtain administrative control of Twitter, including access to tweets that consumers had designated private, and the ability to send out phony tweets pretending to be from then-President-elect Barack Obama and Fox News, among others." The two incidents mentioned involved hackers using password-guessing tools to gain access to administrative functions. Under the settlement, Twitter must maintain a comprehensive information security program, to be assessed by a third-party every other year for 10 years. It also will be prohibited from misleading consumers about the extent to which it maintains and protects the security, privacy and confidentiality of nonpublic consumer information.
Related links:
Twitter Settles Charges that it Failed to Protect Consumers' Personal Information; Company Will Establish Independently Audited Information Security Program
Twitter settles with US regulators over privacy breach - Yahoo! News
Twitter settles with FTC for privacy breach Forrester Blogs
The FTC had alleged that “serious lapses” in Twitter’s security last year "allowed hackers to obtain administrative control of Twitter, including access to tweets that consumers had designated private, and the ability to send out phony tweets pretending to be from then-President-elect Barack Obama and Fox News, among others." The two incidents mentioned involved hackers using password-guessing tools to gain access to administrative functions. Under the settlement, Twitter must maintain a comprehensive information security program, to be assessed by a third-party every other year for 10 years. It also will be prohibited from misleading consumers about the extent to which it maintains and protects the security, privacy and confidentiality of nonpublic consumer information.
Related links:
Twitter Settles Charges that it Failed to Protect Consumers' Personal Information; Company Will Establish Independently Audited Information Security Program
Twitter settles with US regulators over privacy breach - Yahoo! News
Twitter settles with FTC for privacy breach Forrester Blogs
Friday, September 18, 2009
FTC to Hold Data Privacy Roundtables
Here’s an important notice from the Federal Trade Commission -
The FTC will host a series of day-long public roundtable discussions to explore the privacy challenges posed by the vast array of 21st century technology and business practices that collect and use consumer data. Such practices include social networking, cloud computing, online behavioral advertising, mobile marketing, and the collection and use of information by retailers, data brokers, third-party applications, and other diverse businesses. The goal of the roundtables is to determine how best to protect consumer privacy while supporting beneficial uses of the information and technological innovation.
The roundtable discussions will consider the risks and benefits of information collection and use in online and offline contexts, consumer expectations surrounding various information management practices, and the adequacy of existing legal and self-regulatory regimes to address privacy interests. Roundtable participants will include stakeholders representing a wide rangeof views and experiences, such as academics, privacy experts, consumer advocates, industry participants and associations, technology experts, legislators, international representatives, and others.
The Privacy Roundtables are free and open to the public. The first will be held Monday, December 7, 2009, at the FTC Conference Center at 601 New Jersey Avenue, N.W., Washington, DC. Pre-registration is not required. Members of the public and press who wish to participate but who cannot attend can view a live Webcast at FTC.gov. The Commission plans to convene additional roundtables in subsequent months, and will post information regarding these events at a later date.
Links:
FTC to Host Public Roundtables to Address Evolving Consumer Privacy Issues
The FTC will host a series of day-long public roundtable discussions to explore the privacy challenges posed by the vast array of 21st century technology and business practices that collect and use consumer data. Such practices include social networking, cloud computing, online behavioral advertising, mobile marketing, and the collection and use of information by retailers, data brokers, third-party applications, and other diverse businesses. The goal of the roundtables is to determine how best to protect consumer privacy while supporting beneficial uses of the information and technological innovation.
The roundtable discussions will consider the risks and benefits of information collection and use in online and offline contexts, consumer expectations surrounding various information management practices, and the adequacy of existing legal and self-regulatory regimes to address privacy interests. Roundtable participants will include stakeholders representing a wide rangeof views and experiences, such as academics, privacy experts, consumer advocates, industry participants and associations, technology experts, legislators, international representatives, and others.
The Privacy Roundtables are free and open to the public. The first will be held Monday, December 7, 2009, at the FTC Conference Center at 601 New Jersey Avenue, N.W., Washington, DC. Pre-registration is not required. Members of the public and press who wish to participate but who cannot attend can view a live Webcast at FTC.gov. The Commission plans to convene additional roundtables in subsequent months, and will post information regarding these events at a later date.
Links:
FTC to Host Public Roundtables to Address Evolving Consumer Privacy Issues
Thursday, September 17, 2009
IAPP Privacy Academy 2009
The IAPP Privacy Academy is taking place in Boston this week. Privacy professionals from all over the world are gathered to catch up on the latest developments and best practices. I'll blog a bit from the Academy and pass on some of the tidbits.
Thursday, September 10, 2009
Some "light reading" for privacy geeks...
Or, actually, for anyone interested in building privacy into business from the "ground up" and how privacy can (and should) become a business differentiator. Dr. Ann Cavoukian is Ontario's Information and Privacy Commissioner and has long been an advocate of privacy technologies and coined the term "Privacy by Design" in the late-nineties. Her latest book is called exactly that -- "Privacy by Design" and can be downloaded at http://www.privacybydesign.ca/pbdbook/PrivacybyDesignBook.pdf .
It's a must-read for thought leadership in this space.
It's a must-read for thought leadership in this space.
Maine Lawsuit Dismissed and Law "Likely Unconstitutional"
The kerfuffle over the controversial Maine law slated to become effective this week that would have prohibited all marketing to minors has been dismissed. Yesterday, the District of Maine issued a Stipulated Order of Dismissal stating that there is a likelihood that the statute is "overbroad and violates the First Amendment." Further (and perhaps more important to business), Judge Woodcock warned that any individual lawsuits brought under the statute’s private right of action would likely face the same fate -- dismissal. "[T]hird parties are on notice that a private cause of action under Chapter 230 could suffer from the same constitutional infirmities" that resulted in his finding that the law was likely overbroad, Woodcock concluded.
In the meantime, the lawsuit was dismissed without prejudice in light of the Attorney General’s representation to the Court that Maine will not enforce the statute and that the Legislature will reconsider it when they reconvene in January 2010.
Other links:
eWeek
Portland Press Herald
In the meantime, the lawsuit was dismissed without prejudice in light of the Attorney General’s representation to the Court that Maine will not enforce the statute and that the Legislature will reconsider it when they reconvene in January 2010.
Other links:
eWeek
Portland Press Herald
Thursday, September 3, 2009
Maine AG - I Will Not Enforce New Marketing Law
It looks as though Maine’s Attorney General will not enforce a controversial new state law that restricts marketing to minors, but has drawn a federal lawsuit because plaintiffs argued that the law swept too broadly. The Wall Street Journal today reports that a spokesperson for Maine AG Janet Mills said that Mills will not be enforcing the law and will work with sponsors to amend the legislation when Maine’s legislature reconvenes in January, 2010. One caution here, though -- the Maine law contains a private right of action which means that, although the AG has decided against enforcement, a private party could still bring an individual suit ---- or a class action. Stay tuned.
Wednesday, September 2, 2009
Low Tech ID Theft ......
As Federal Reserve Chairman Ben Bernanke and his wife recently found out, identity theft often has nothing to do with technology….
PC Mag: Fed Chairman Hit by ID Theft
PC Mag: Fed Chairman Hit by ID Theft
Wednesday, July 8, 2009
What is happening with Registered Traveler data? It's not "Clear"....
As I blogged a few weeks back, the "Clear" Registered Traveler program abruptly ended because the service provider ceased operations. The announcement at the time raised the questions of what happens to the vast trove of personal information and biometric data that the company collected in order to "clear" frequent fliers who ponied up the $199 annual fee. Those questions have still not been completely answered, and just before the holiday, the Chairman of the House Committee on Homeland Security sent a letter to the Transportation Security Administration asking the same questions........and giving TSA until July 8th to explain how the agency plans to ensure the security of the data.
Chairman Thompson wants TSA to explain what role it will take in ensuring that "adequate privacy protections are in place prior to any disposition of the personally identifiable information." The TSA has posted an FAQ on its website directing questions about Clear back to the vendor.
We have learned a bit more from Verified Identity Pass (VIP), the company that operated the Clear program. VIP has issued a statement regarding the handling of existing data on hardware -- airport kiosks and computers assigned to VIP employees. According to VIP, all such equipment was being cleared using a process known as "triple wiping," which is a reliable method for clearing hard disks of data. Once the information has been wiped, Clear says that it will send members one final email confirming that their information has been deleted from the kiosks and computers.
None of this addresses the issue of the central database. What we do not know -- and will not know until it happens -- is whether the data will be sold. VIP has not filed for protection under the Bankruptcy Code and is presumably trying to sell itself to another Registered Traveler service provider (there are 8 approved by TSA). In the FAQ, the company's response was that "(t)he personally identifiable information that customers provided to Clear may not be used for any purpose other than a Registered Traveler program operated by a Transportation Security Administration authorized service provider." Short answer, if it can find a buyer that is a TSA-authorized RT provider, your data will most certainly be sold. Clear says nothing about informing members that their information will be transferred to another provider in a sale of what is left of the company, or obtaining consent to such a transfer.
All of this illustrates a ticking time bomb in difficult economic times --- what happens to the myriad of personal and financial data that a failing or failed company has collected during the time it was in business?? Databases and customer lists are assets that can be converted to cash to pay creditors. Hardware is often sold for scrap without "triple wiping" or is just transferred to a new buyer.
Good discussion of the Clear program issues at ComputerWorld.
Chairman Thompson wants TSA to explain what role it will take in ensuring that "adequate privacy protections are in place prior to any disposition of the personally identifiable information." The TSA has posted an FAQ on its website directing questions about Clear back to the vendor.
We have learned a bit more from Verified Identity Pass (VIP), the company that operated the Clear program. VIP has issued a statement regarding the handling of existing data on hardware -- airport kiosks and computers assigned to VIP employees. According to VIP, all such equipment was being cleared using a process known as "triple wiping," which is a reliable method for clearing hard disks of data. Once the information has been wiped, Clear says that it will send members one final email confirming that their information has been deleted from the kiosks and computers.
None of this addresses the issue of the central database. What we do not know -- and will not know until it happens -- is whether the data will be sold. VIP has not filed for protection under the Bankruptcy Code and is presumably trying to sell itself to another Registered Traveler service provider (there are 8 approved by TSA). In the FAQ, the company's response was that "(t)he personally identifiable information that customers provided to Clear may not be used for any purpose other than a Registered Traveler program operated by a Transportation Security Administration authorized service provider." Short answer, if it can find a buyer that is a TSA-authorized RT provider, your data will most certainly be sold. Clear says nothing about informing members that their information will be transferred to another provider in a sale of what is left of the company, or obtaining consent to such a transfer.
All of this illustrates a ticking time bomb in difficult economic times --- what happens to the myriad of personal and financial data that a failing or failed company has collected during the time it was in business?? Databases and customer lists are assets that can be converted to cash to pay creditors. Hardware is often sold for scrap without "triple wiping" or is just transferred to a new buyer.
Good discussion of the Clear program issues at ComputerWorld.
Friday, June 19, 2009
Congress to Bring "Law and Order" to the Internet??
In February, the Federal Trade Commission released its report on behavioral advertising "guidelines," with strong suggestion over the recent weeks from Commissioner Jon Liebowitz that without significant self-regulation, the online advertising industry could see regulation or legislation. We discussed the FTC report at that time here.
Republican Joe Barton of Texas, ranking member of the House Energy & Commerce Committee, had the soundbite of the day. Although he commended industry for some measure of self-regulation, Barton said that it may be time for Congress to "to bring some law and order" to what is "still a bit of a Wild West area." "I think it's a big deal if somebody tracks where you go and what you look at without your personal approval," Barton continued. "We wouldn't like that in the non-Internet world, and I personally don't like it in the Internet world."
Yesterday, two House committees came together to look at privacy implications of online advertising and discuss such esoteric topics as deep packet inspection. The joint hearing of the House Communications, Technology and the Internet Subcommittee and the Subcommittee on Commerce, Trade, and Consumer Protection on Behavioral Advertising: Industry Practices and Consumers' Experiences was webcast.
Republican Joe Barton of Texas, ranking member of the House Energy & Commerce Committee, had the soundbite of the day. Although he commended industry for some measure of self-regulation, Barton said that it may be time for Congress to "to bring some law and order" to what is "still a bit of a Wild West area." "I think it's a big deal if somebody tracks where you go and what you look at without your personal approval," Barton continued. "We wouldn't like that in the non-Internet world, and I personally don't like it in the Internet world."
"Opt-in" Coming to the US?
Democrat Rick Boucher of Virginia chairs one of the subcommittees and is expected to introduce a general privacy bill with other committee members. In the hearing, Boucher called for what he called "baseline" consumer protections. In that group, he included a requirement that consumers be allowed to "opt in" to use of their personal information by third parties. The shift from "opt out" to "opt in" would be a significant change for US online advertisers and retailers, but would actually bring the US in line with practices in Canada and the European Union.
Both Boucher and ranking communications subcommittee member Rep. Cliff Stearns (R-FL) acknowledged the need to balance consumer-centric privacy protection regulation with the potential for negative economic impact on a $300 billion US industry in a time of economic downturn. Boucher said that he had "no intention of disrupting this business model." Stearns echoed that sentiment: "We want to do no harm here."
The FTC's letter is available here
Testimony is available on the committee's web site at Hearing Webcast
Thursday, June 18, 2009
FTC Issues Consent Order for GLBA Violations
In the run-up to the enforcement deadline for the Identity Theft Red Flag Rule (August 1, 2009 - more on that in another post), enforcement of the Gramm-Leach-Bliley Privacy Rule and Safeguards Rule has not been forgotten by the Federal Trade Commission.
This week, the FTC issued a consent order against mortgage lender James B. Nutter & Company for violations of GLBA resulting from the company's lack of an adequate information security program and safeguards.
This consent order, like similar orders issued by the FTC of late, provides a blueprint for executives and compliance officers: there are consequences that directly result from the failures to implement reasonable information security and privacy programs. The FTC order requires, among other things, that James B. Nutter & Company implement a comprehensive security program, and engage a third-party professional to perform an initial assessment of that program, followed by biennial assessments for 10 years. Compliance with an FTC consent order is more costly than establishing a compliance program from the start.
Links:
The FTC announcement
The FTC complaint
The Agreement and Consent Order
This week, the FTC issued a consent order against mortgage lender James B. Nutter & Company for violations of GLBA resulting from the company's lack of an adequate information security program and safeguards.
This consent order, like similar orders issued by the FTC of late, provides a blueprint for executives and compliance officers: there are consequences that directly result from the failures to implement reasonable information security and privacy programs. The FTC order requires, among other things, that James B. Nutter & Company implement a comprehensive security program, and engage a third-party professional to perform an initial assessment of that program, followed by biennial assessments for 10 years. Compliance with an FTC consent order is more costly than establishing a compliance program from the start.
Links:
The FTC announcement
The FTC complaint
The Agreement and Consent Order
Labels:
consent order,
FTC,
GLBA,
information security,
privacy,
Red Flag,
safeguards
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)