Wednesday, July 28, 2010
Improper Disposal Costs Rite Aid $1 Million
Rite Aid has agreed to pay $1 million to settle allegations that it violated HIPAA by disposing of labeled pill bottles in unsecured dumpsters accessible to the public. The $1 million fine settles a joint Office of Civil Rights (OCR)/Federal Trade Commission (FTC) investigation prompted by televised media reports of pharmacies disposing of pill bottles containing patient information. Rite Aid and several other retail pharmacies in cities throughout the United Sates were highlighted in the report.
The improper disposal of patient labels violates the HIPAA Privacy Rule (not the security rule, because the labels are paper) and exposes patients to the risk of identity theft and other crimes.
In addition to paying the $1 million resolution amount to OCR, Rite Aid has agreed to implement “a strong corrective action program” including:
· Revising its policies and procedures related to the disposal of PHI and sanctioning workers who do not follow them
· Training workforce members on new policies and procedures
· Conducting internal monitoring
· Engaging a qualified, independent third party assessor to review its compliance efforts and report to HHS
A link to the resolution agreement is available here: http://www.hhs.gov/ocr/privacy/hipaa/enforcement/examples/riteaidres.pdf
Thursday, July 8, 2010
First Ever State-initiated HIPAA Enforcement Action Settled
Connecticut Attorney General Richard Blumenthal has settled the first state-initiated HIPAA enforcement action. The settlement totals $250,000 in statutory damages and Health Net's agreement to implement a variety of measures to improve the security of consumer health and personal information. Health Net also agreed to provide two years of credit monitoring to affected individuals, $1 million of identity theft insurance and reimbursement for the costs of security freezes.
As we reported in this space, Blumenthal sued Health Net and its affiliates after they allegedly lost a computer disk drive in May 2009 containing protected health and other private information on more than 500,000 Connecticut residents and 1.5 million consumers nationwide. The missing disk drive contained names, addresses, social security numbers, protected health information and financial information. Blumenthal also alleged that Health Net failed to promptly notify consumers endangered by the breach even after learning that the disk drive was stolen.
The Health Net case is the first action by a state attorney general for HIPAA violations since the Health Information Technology for Economic and Clinical Health Act (HITECH) authorized state attorneys general to enforce HIPAA.
The full text of the settlement is available here:
http://www.ct.gov/ag/lib/ag/fraud/soctvhealthnetstipjudgment.pdf
Monday, April 26, 2010
Proposed HITECH Regulations Out in May?
The Department is also scheduled to issue a final rule in May of this year, addressing the certification standards and implementation criteria for electronic health record technology.
Friday, March 26, 2010
HHS Announces Delay in Enforcement of HITECH Rules as Applied to Business Associates
We take this to mean that enforcement of these particular HITECH Act provisions will be delayed.
For more information, see the Mintz Levin Health Law and Employee Benefits Alert just published.
Wednesday, March 24, 2010
Quick Compliance Survey
Click here to take survey
Monday, February 22, 2010
Today's compliance deadline - Enforcement of the HITECH/HIPAA data breach notification rule
Today is the day that the Health & Human Services Office of Civil Rights begins to enforce the HITECH/HIPAA data breach notification rule. To "celebrate" the occasion, the agency publicly posted the first list of reported breaches affecting 500 or more individuals. The list is available on the HHS’ website, but I thought I would post them here. Reasonably instructive…..see any trends??
Breaches Affecting 500 or More Individuals
As required by section 13402(e)(4) of the HITECH Act, the Secretary must post a list of breaches of unsecured protected health information affecting 500 or more individuals. The following breaches have been reported to the Secretary.
The Methodist Hospital
State:
Texas
Approx. # of Individuals Affected:
689
Date of Breach:
1/18/10
Type of Breach:
Theft
Location of Breached Information:
Computer
Carle Clinic Association
State:
Illinois
Approx. # of Individuals Affected:
1,300
Date of Breach:
1/13/10
Type of Breach:
Theft
Location of Breached Information:
Paper Records and Films
Ashley and Gray DDS
State:
Missouri
Approx. # of Individuals Affected:
9,309
Date of Breach:
1/10/10
Type of Breach:
Theft
Location of Breached Information:
Desktop Computer
Educators Mutual Insurance Association of Utah
State:
Utah
Business Associate Involved:
Health Behavior Innovations
Approx. # of Individuals Affected:
5,700
Date of Breach:
12/27/09
Type of Breach:
Theft
Location of Breached Information:
CDs
Goodwill Industries of Greater Grand Rapids, Inc.
State:
Michigan
Approx. # of Individuals Affected:
10,000
Date of Breach:
12/15/09
Type of Breach:
Theft
Location of Breached Information:
Backup Tapes
Private Practice
City and State:
Stoughton, MA
Approx. # of Individuals Affected:
1,860
Date of Breach:
12/11/09
Type of Breach:
Theft
Location of Breached Information:
Portable Electronic Device/Electronic Medical Record
AvMed, Inc.
State:
Florida
Approx. # of Individuals Affected:
359,000
Date of Breach:
12/10/09
Type of Breach:
Theft
Location of Breached Information:
Laptop
Blue Island Radiology Consultants
State:
Illinois
Business Associate Involved:
United Micro Data
Approx. # of Individuals Affected:
2,562
Date of Breach:
12/09/09
Type of Breach:
Loss
Location of Breached Information:
Backup Tapes
Private Practice
City and State:
Wilmington, NC
Business Associate Involved:
Rick Lawson, Professional Computer Services
Approx. # of Individuals Affected:
2,000
Date of Breach:
12/08/09
Type of Breach:
Hacking/IT Incident
Location of Breached Information:
Computer/Network Server/Electronic Medical Record
Kaiser Permanente Medical Care Program
State:
California
Approx. # of Individuals Affected:
15,500
Date of Breach:
12/01/09
Type of Breach:
Theft
Location of Breached Information:
Portable Electronic Device
University of California, San Francisco
State:
California
Approx. # of Individuals Affected:
7,300
Date of Breach:
11/30/09
Type of Breach:
Theft
Location of Breached Information:
Laptop
Detroit Department of Health and Wellness Promotion
State:
Michigan
Approx. # of Individuals Affected:
646
Date of Breach:
11/26/09
Type of Breach:
Theft
Location of Breached Information:
Laptop, Desktop Computer
Advocate Health Care
State:
Illinois
Approx. # of Individuals Affected:
812
Date of Breach:
11/24/09
Type of Breach:
Theft
Location of Breached Information:
Laptop
Concentra
State:
Texas
Approx. # of Individuals Affected:
900
Date of Breach:
11/19/09
Type of Breach:
Theft
Location of Breached Information:
Laptop
Children's Medical Center of Dallas
State:
Texas
Approx. # of Individuals Affected:
3,800
Date of Breach:
11/19/09
Type of Breach:
Loss
Location of Breached Information:
Portable Electronic Device
Universal American, Inc.
State:
New York
Business Associate Involved:
Democracy Data & Communications, LLC
Approx. # of Individuals Affected:
83,000
Date of Breach:
11/12/09
Type of Breach:
Incorrect Mailing
Location of Breached Information:
Postcards
Massachusetts Eye and Ear Infirmary
State:
Massachusetts
Approx. # of Individuals Affected:
1,076
Date of Breach:
11/10/09
Type of Breach:
Theft
Location of Breached Information:
Other
Kern Medical Center
State:
California
Approx. # of Individuals Affected:
596
Date of Breach:
10/31/09
Type of Breach:
Theft
Location of Breached Information:
Paper Records
Blue Cross Blue Shield Association
State:
District of Columbia
Business Associate Involved:
Service Benefits Plan Administrative Services Corp.
Approx. # of Individuals Affected:
3,400
Date of Breach:
10/26/09
Type of Breach:
Unauthorized Access
Location of Breached Information:
Mailings
Detroit Department of Health and Wellness Promotion
State:
Michigan
Approx. # of Individuals Affected:
10,000
Date of Breach:
10/22/09
Type of Breach:
Theft
Location of Breached Information:
Portable Electronic Device
The Children's Hospital of Philadelphia
State:
Pennsylvania
Approx. # of Individuals Affected:
943
Date of Breach:
10/20/09
Type of Breach:
Theft
Location of Breached Information:
Laptop
Public Employee Health Insurance Plan (Kentucky Employees' Health Plan)
State:
Kentucky
Approx. # of Individuals Affected:
676
Date of Breach:
10/20/09
Type of Breach:
Misdirected E-mail
Location of Breached Information:
Brooke Army Medical Center
State:
Texas
Approx. # of Individuals Affected:
1,000
Date of Breach:
10/16/09
Type of Breach:
Theft
Location of Breached Information:
Paper Records
Alaska Department of Health and Social Services
State:
Alaska
Approx. # of Individuals Affected:
501
Date of Breach:
10/12/09
Type of Breach:
Theft
Location of Breached Information:
Portable USB Device
Cogent Healthcare of Wisconsin, S.C.
State:
Tennessee
Business Associate Involved:
Cogent Healthcare, Inc.
Approx. # of Individuals Affected:
6,400
Date of Breach:
10/11/09
Type of Breach:
Theft
Location of Breached Information:
Laptop
Health Services for Children with Special Needs, Inc.
State:
District of Columbia
Approx. # of Individuals Affected:
3,800
Date of Breach:
10/09/09
Type of Breach:
Loss
Location of Breached Information:
Laptop
Blue Cross Blue Shield Association
State:
District of Columbia
Business Associate Involved:
Merkle Direct Marketing
Approx. # of Individuals Affected:
15,000
Date of Breach:
10/07/09
Type of Breach:
Unauthorized Access
Location of Breached Information:
Mailings
Blue Cross Blue Shield of Tennessee
State:
Tennessee
Approx. # of Individuals Affected:
500,000
Date of Breach:
10/02/09
Type of Breach:
Theft
Location of Breached Information:
Hard Drives
City of Hope National Medical Center
State:
California
Approx. # of Individuals Affected:
5,900
Date of Breach:
9/27/09
Type of Breach:
Theft
Location of Breached Information:
Laptop
Private Practice
City and State:
Torrance, CA
Approx. # of Individuals Affected:
6,145
Date of Breach:
9/27/09
Type of Breach:
Theft, Unauthorized Access
Location of Breached Information:
Desktop Computer
Private Practice
City and State:
Torrance, CA
Approx. # of Individuals Affected:
5,166
Date of Breach:
9/27/09
Type of Breach:
Theft, Unauthorized Access
Location of Breached Information:
Desktop Computer
Private Practice
City and State:
Torrance, CA
Approx. # of Individuals Affected:
5,257
Date of Breach:
9/27/09
Type of Breach:
Theft, Unauthorized Access
Location of Breached Information:
Desktop Computer
Private Practice
City and State:
Torrance, CA
Approx. # of Individuals Affected:
857
Date of Breach:
9/27/09
Type of Breach:
Theft, Unauthorized Access
Location of Breached Information:
Desktop Computer
Private Practice
City and State:
Torrance, CA
Approx. # of Individuals Affected:
952
Date of Breach:
9/27/09
Type of Breach:
Theft, Unauthorized Access
Location of Breached Information:
Desktop Computer
University of California, San Francisco
State:
California
Approx. # of Individuals Affected:
610
Date of Breach:
9/22/09
Type of Breach:
Phishing Scam
Location of Breached Information:
Mid America Kidney Stone Association, LLC
State:
Missouri
Approx. # of Individuals Affected:
1,000
Date of Breach:
9/22/09
Type of Breach:
Theft
Location of Breached Information:
Network Server
HITECH Act Compliance Date Arrived -- Without the Promised Regulatory Guidance
The HITECH Act was passed as part of the “Stimulus Bill” on February 17, 2009. Although rumors continue to swirl that additional regulations will be forthcoming shortly (the latest rumor is that the East Coast blizzard slowed down the review and approval process), it is clear that they were not out as of the February 17th effective date. Therefore, covered entities and their business associates must act immediately on the terms of the HITECH statute itself.
HITECH imposes new HIPAA rules on covered entities and their business associates. New data breach notification rules require covered entities to review any possible wrongful disclosures to determine whether to warn individuals or notify the federal government or the press. Covered entities should have policies in place to meet these requirements in the event of a breach. Covered entities should review and revise their business associate agreements and their other policies and procedures as well.
HITECH also makes most HIPAA rules applicable directly to business associates. If your company serves healthcare providers or insurance plans (including group health plans), and you receive health information, you are probably a business associate and are covered by these changes. Most importantly, business associates must adopt HIPAA policies and procedures to protect the security of the information they collect, hold and use. In addition to the contractual obligations business associate agreements put on them, business associates are now directly liable under HIPAA.
Thursday, January 28, 2010
Data Privacy Day -- Tip #4 -- Transactional Best Practices for Lawyers
Even though lawyers working on both sides of an M&A transaction during the due diligence phase might immerse themselves in a “confidentiality bubble”, they still must be careful not to disclose or access confidential employee information in the course of that transaction. Attorneys evaluating potential transactions might be tempted to access information regarding target employees, such as personnel files, compensation information, and information concerning performance evaluation and other historical employment information. Transactional attorneys are often surprised to learn that dissemination of some of this information, even among those subject to a confidentiality agreement, may violate an employee’s privacy rights and even violate the law.
Some states preclude employers from disclosing employee personnel information or from revealing information regarding employee compensation altogether while other states require a waiver from the employee as a condition to dissemination to any third parties. Federal and many states laws make it illegal for companies to disclose employee medical records without authorization, and this is particularly a concern where those records include personal health information and may implicate newly-expanded HIPAA regulations. Personnel files of employees that are Massachusetts residents will contain "personal information" that can only be transmitted in compliance with the Massachusetts regulations. In the cross-border M&A context, "personal data" of employees can only be transferred to the U.S. (or to U.S. persons) in compliance with applicable data protection laws in their country of residence/employment -- and in most cases can only be with the employee's consent. Even documents in a digital "data room" that can be accessed from the U.S. may fall afoul of data protection laws in other countries.
Companies must ensure that they have the proper mechanisms in place to minimize the exposure of personnel information during a contemplated transaction, including having a good understanding as to what legally may and may not be provided to potential acquirers, and securing any necessary waivers from employees prior to turning that information over in the due diligence process.
And finally, storage and disposal of due diligence files containing personal information or protected health information must be handled in accordance with applicable state and federal laws. If you don't keep it, you can't lose it!
Data Privacy Day Tip #2 - HITECH Act
Effective February 17, 2010, significant new compliance obligations will be imposed on business associates through the HITECH provisions of the American Recovery and Reinvestment Act of 2009 ("ARRA"). Business associates (or organizations that use or disclose protected health information on behalf of covered entities subject to HIPAA) will be directly liable for compliance with certain provisions of the HIPAA Privacy Rule and the HIPAA Security Standards, and may be audited by the Department of Health and Human Services ("HHS"). They will also be subject to increased civil and criminal penalties for non-compliance.
DATA PRIVACY DAY REMINDER: Time to update business associate agreements to reflect HITECH's new breach-notice provisions and other requirements. Business associates must also--at a minimum--(i) undertake and complete a security risk assessment, (ii) prepare and adopt written security policies and procedures, and (iii) conduct workforce training in their policies and procedures.
Link to blog post for more information:
Privacy and Security Information - Privacy MATTERS: Federal Breach Notification Rules -- NEXT WEEK. Are you ready?
Friday, January 15, 2010
Connecticut Attorney General Brings Charges Against Health Net for HIPAA Violations
Written by Dianne Bourque
On January 13, Connecticut Attorney General Richard Blumenthal filed charges against Health Net of Connecticut, Inc., for violating federal privacy law. Blumenthal is the first state attorney general to file such a suit using HIPAA enforcement authority granted to states under the HITECH provisions of the American Recovery and Reinvestment Act of 2009.
The law suit was prompted by Health Net’s loss of a portable disk drive from a Connecticut office. The unencrypted drive contained health and other personal information for approximately 1.5 million current and former Health Net members. Almost one-half million of the affected members were Connecticut residents.
In a statement, Health Net said that it would cooperate with the Attorney General and that there is no evidence that any of the lost data had been misused.
Tuesday, December 22, 2009
Data Security Roundtable
http://www.businesswire.com/portal/site/home/permalink/?ndmViewId=news_view&newsId=20091222005345&newsLang=en
Some very interesting discussions with folks who are on the cutting edge of data security. I'll post the other segments as they are released.
Friday, November 13, 2009
Some startling statistics regarding social networking issues in the workplace......
The Journal of the American Medical Association published a the results of an eye-popping study in the September issue. In response to a survey conducted by the Health Care Compliance Association (HCCA) and the Society of Corporate Compliance and Ethics (SCCE), only 38 percent of survey respondents said that they have policies to cover online conduct. The “status update” features of social media platforms encourages people to record what they’re working on or who they are meeting with -- jeopardizing personal information and confidentiality.
Related Links
Mintz Levin Client Alert - HCCA/SCCE Survey
Social media behavior could threaten your reputation, job prospects :: Oct. 12, 2009 ... American Medical News
Medical students using Facebook and Twitter can get expelled
Friday, September 25, 2009
Check your employee handbook - what you might think is fraud and abuse may not be a federal case....
interesting decision drawing attention to the need for clear and explicit policies regarding "acceptable use" of computers and company information and the absolute necessity to terminate access once an employee or contractor is terminated.
Particularly in light of the upcoming Massachusetts data security regulations, permitting employees (contract or otherwise) to email unencrypted documents containing personal information of customers/clients/employees outside of the organization to be stored on a home computer (similarly unencrypted, one can presume) will be a violation of 201 CMR 17.00 if that list contains "Personal Information" of Massachusetts residents, and failing to have procedures as part of your information security plan that terminates access to such information for former employees will also be a violation. Similarly, because a health care provider and protected health information is involved here, this action would be in violation of the new HHS guidelines for the handling of PHI and, finally, because the defendant was no longer authorized to have the information, it was likely a reportable breach under HIPAA and many state laws.
For all that the incident is, it seems that the Ninth Circuit does not find that it was a violation of the federal Computer Fraud and Abuse Act.
Friday, September 18, 2009
Federal Breach Notification Rules -- NEXT WEEK. Are you ready?
New federal breach notification rules go into effect next week for covered entities and their business associates and also for vendors of personal health records.
Covered entities (organizations subject to the HIPAA privacy rule) and their business associates must report breaches of unsecured protected health information in accordance with new rules from the Department of Health and Human Services (HHS) starting Wednesday, September 23, 2009. Unsecured protected health information is information that has not been either encrypted or destroyed in accordance with HHS standards. Note that under the rules, a covered entity may not have to report a breach of unsecured protected health information if, after conducting a risk analysis, it believes in good faith that the unauthorized recipient of the PHI would not reasonably have been able to retain it (for example, if misdirected patient correspondence is returned as undeliverable and is unopened).
The breach notification regulations require prompt notification to affected individuals, as well as to the HHS Secretary and the media in cases where a breach affects more than 500 individuals. Breaches affecting fewer than 500 individuals must be reported to the HHS Secretary on an annual basis. The regulations also require business associates of covered entities to notify the covered entity of breaches by the business associate.
The HHS regulations were developed in close consultation with the Federal Trade Commission (FTC), which has issued companion breach notification regulations that apply to vendors of personal health records and certain others not covered by HIPAA. The FTC regulations are effective September 24, 2009. The rules are identical with respect to some provisions, similar in others, and completely different in a few others. Those differences can matter because some organizations will be covered by both regulations.
Both the FTC and HHS intend for their regulations’ notices to be combined with the state-required notices, so that a consumer would receive only a single notice. The agencies’ requirements for the content of the notices are practically identical, but the regulations have many differing requirements on a wide range of topics. For example, HHS’ requirements extend to breaches of health information in all formats, including paper, whereas the FTC’s requirements extend only to health information in electronic form. Also remember, there will be different state requirements for notice, some of which (particularly in Massachusetts) will conflict with the FTC/HHS content.
Links:
Text of HHS Breach Notification Rule
Text of FTC Breach Notification Rule
Mintz Matrix of State Data Breach Notification Laws, current as of August 31, 2009