Friday, August 6, 2010
Patient privacy group welcomes HHS withdrawal of HITECH Act breach notification rule
The Foundation called the withdrawal a "huge step in the right direction" and reiterated its disappointment with the 'harm threshold' provision, which allows health care providers to conduct a risk assessment of any data breach, before deciding whether it is necessary to report the breach to HHS. "The broad discretion granted to industry goes far beyond Congressional intent", read the Foundation's submission sent to HHS during the 2009 public comment period. "There was no mention of any consideration of a harm standard in HHS previous Request for Information, thus thwarting any opportunity for public debate." Several Congressmen also submitted comments to the HHS, expressing concerns over the breadth of discretion that would be given to companies, "particularly with regard to determining something as subjective as harm from the release of sensitive and personal information."
HHS is expected to publish a final rule in the Federal Register in the coming months.
Friday, July 30, 2010
HHS Withdraws Breach Notification Final Rule (but breach notification still effective)
Breach Notification Final Rule Update
The Interim Final Rule for Breach Notification for Unsecured Protected Health Information, issued pursuant to the Health Information Technology for Economic and Clinical Health (HITECH) Act, was published in the Federal Register on August 24, 2009, and became effective on September 23, 2009. During the 60-day public comment period on the Interim Final Rule, HHS received approximately 120 comments.
HHS reviewed the public comment on the interim rule and developed a final rule, which was submitted to the Office of Management and Budget (OMB) for Executive Order 12866 regulatory review on May 14, 2010. At this time, however, HHS is withdrawing the breach notification final rule from OMB review to allow for further consideration, given the Department's experience to date in administering the regulations. This is a complex issue and the Administration is committed to ensuring that individuals' health information is secured to the extent possible to avoid unauthorized uses and disclosures, and that individuals are appropriately notified when incidents do occur. We intend to publish a final rule in the Federal Register in the coming months.
Thursday, July 1, 2010
Data Breaches du Jour
Update on Major Data Breach at California Health Insurer
Updating a previous blog post (link) from Monday, WellPoint, the country's largest health insurer, has now sent notice to 470,000 members and applicants for individual health insurance nationwide informing them of a breach to a web site used by individuals to apply for insurance and track the status of their applications. The web site system run by WellPoint subsidiary Anthem Blue Cross of California was allegedly manipulated by attorneys looking to bolster a class action lawsuit against the insurer. WellPoint indicated that although the breach may have affected 230,000 California customers as previously reported, data for other applicants could have been obtained and accessed by anyone merely by altering the URL, thus prompting the additional notices.
While initially saying that personal information was unsecure for "a relatively short period of time," WellPoint now explains that five months passed before the company learned in March that a failed security update to the Anthem web site left customers' data vulnerable.
Related Link:
http://www.govinfosecurity.com/articles.php?art_id=2690
Unencrypted Patient Information Goes Missing from NY Hospital
A New York hospital is notifying some 130,000 patients that their personal information may have been compromised. Patient information stored on seven CDs belonging to New York's Lincoln Medical and Mental Health Center was lost in transit after a hospital contractor shipped them, Bloomberg reports. The unencrypted data includes Social Security numbers, dates of birth, drivers' license numbers and procedure information. In a letter sent to victims earlier this month, the hospital suggested the CDs may have been displaced at a shipping facility and destroyed.
Yet another good example for encryption of all PHI and PI in transit.
Related Link:
http://www.businessweek.com/idg/2010-06-29/new-york-hospital-loses-data-on-130-000-via-fedex.html
Continuing Data Breach Over Eight Year Period Exposes Personal and Medical Records of Students at University of Maine Counseling Center
According to the Auburn-Lewiston Sun Journal, the University of Maine Police Department is investigating a data breach that exposed nearly 5,000 students' personal and medical information. Starting in 2002 and spanning eight years, hackers accessed the UMaine counseling center database, the Sun Journal reports. The database stored information including names, Social Security numbers and clinical information. The university has hired a company to monitor the credit of those potentially affected, though there is no indication the hacked data has been viewed or used. "This is a serious breach and we are profoundly sorry that this has happened," said a university spokesman.
Related Link:
http://www.sunjournal.com/state/story/870870
Friday, June 25, 2010
July 13 Data Security Workshop - FREE
- What are my organization and business partner’s obligations?
- What kind of information do I need to protect and how do identify it?
- Is data encryption necessary?
- What is a WISP?
- What is a data breach and what is my responsibility and liability if I have one?
For information or to register to attend the event, which will be hosted by Mintz Levin in our downtown Boston office, please click this link: http://tinyurl.com/35pk3yr
Thursday, April 8, 2010
Mississippi Becomes 46th State to Enact Data Breach Notification Law
Similar to most of the other laws, the Mississippi law applies to any person who owns, licenses or maintains computerized personal information of any resident of that state. Breaches must be disclosed “without unreasonable delay.” It does not appear that the Mississippi law imposes any out-of –the-ordinary obligations on businesses, but the trend continues. The law becomes effective July 1, 2011.
Link to text of legislation:
HB 583 (As Sent to Governor) - 2010 Regular Session
Tuesday, March 30, 2010
Government "Outs" Mystery Retailers in Gonzalez Hack Case
J.C. Penney argued unsuccessfully last week to keep the company’s identity under seal, and that it (a corporation) was entitled to anonymity under the 2004 Crime Victims' Rights Act. That law was intended to protect the “dignity and privacy” of victims – and that is what Penney argued. but Judge Douglas P. Woodcock was not convinced -- and in fact was "astonished." The Judge said in the hearing that he believed both retailers should have announced their involvement from the start and that consumers had the right to know. Woodlock said he would not provide the companies “insulation from transparency.”
For more: StorefrontBacktalk » JC Penney, Wet Seal: Gonzalez Mystery Merchants
Motion of Government - http://www.wired.com/images_blogs/threatlevel/2010/03/09-cr-10382-14.pdf
Thursday, March 11, 2010
Big Fines Coming in UK for Data Breaches
As of April 6, 2010, the UK’s Information Commissioner’s Office (ICO) can levy fines of up to £500,000 for breaches of the Data Protection Act 1998 that are:
• serious in nature
• deliberate or reckless, and
• likely to cause substantial damage or distress to an individual.
The standard for “reckless” non-compliance may take some by surprise: Did the data controller know, or should it have known, that there was a risk of a breach of a kind likely to cause substantial damage or distress? If so, were reasonable steps were taken to prevent the breach?
The ICO has given a specific example that may make IT and privacy officers flinch, but will come as no surprise to those in the U.S. who have been dealing with the likes of Massachusetts 201 CMR 17.00 or the HITECH Act: Does the company have appropriate policies and procedures in place such as the encryption of all laptops and removable media (such as flash drives) to avoid loss of personal data if an employee’s laptop or removable media is stolen? Failing to do so might be considered “reckless” depending on the likely consequences of the loss of personal data contained in the unsecured devices.
Further Information
For more information, see our our Mintz Levin Client Alert. Also, the ICO has published detailed guidance concerning when fines will be issued, the process for trying to get fines withdrawn or reduced, how to appeal, and payment.
Thursday, March 4, 2010
Major "goof" at Citibank
Check this out at WalletPop
Tuesday, March 2, 2010
Hotel Chain Hacked Again....
Related Links
Letter posted to Wyndham website
V3 UK - Wyndham Hotel Chain Hacked Again
Monday, February 22, 2010
Today's compliance deadline - Enforcement of the HITECH/HIPAA data breach notification rule
Today is the day that the Health & Human Services Office of Civil Rights begins to enforce the HITECH/HIPAA data breach notification rule. To "celebrate" the occasion, the agency publicly posted the first list of reported breaches affecting 500 or more individuals. The list is available on the HHS’ website, but I thought I would post them here. Reasonably instructive…..see any trends??
Breaches Affecting 500 or More Individuals
As required by section 13402(e)(4) of the HITECH Act, the Secretary must post a list of breaches of unsecured protected health information affecting 500 or more individuals. The following breaches have been reported to the Secretary.
The Methodist Hospital
State:
Texas
Approx. # of Individuals Affected:
689
Date of Breach:
1/18/10
Type of Breach:
Theft
Location of Breached Information:
Computer
Carle Clinic Association
State:
Illinois
Approx. # of Individuals Affected:
1,300
Date of Breach:
1/13/10
Type of Breach:
Theft
Location of Breached Information:
Paper Records and Films
Ashley and Gray DDS
State:
Missouri
Approx. # of Individuals Affected:
9,309
Date of Breach:
1/10/10
Type of Breach:
Theft
Location of Breached Information:
Desktop Computer
Educators Mutual Insurance Association of Utah
State:
Utah
Business Associate Involved:
Health Behavior Innovations
Approx. # of Individuals Affected:
5,700
Date of Breach:
12/27/09
Type of Breach:
Theft
Location of Breached Information:
CDs
Goodwill Industries of Greater Grand Rapids, Inc.
State:
Michigan
Approx. # of Individuals Affected:
10,000
Date of Breach:
12/15/09
Type of Breach:
Theft
Location of Breached Information:
Backup Tapes
Private Practice
City and State:
Stoughton, MA
Approx. # of Individuals Affected:
1,860
Date of Breach:
12/11/09
Type of Breach:
Theft
Location of Breached Information:
Portable Electronic Device/Electronic Medical Record
AvMed, Inc.
State:
Florida
Approx. # of Individuals Affected:
359,000
Date of Breach:
12/10/09
Type of Breach:
Theft
Location of Breached Information:
Laptop
Blue Island Radiology Consultants
State:
Illinois
Business Associate Involved:
United Micro Data
Approx. # of Individuals Affected:
2,562
Date of Breach:
12/09/09
Type of Breach:
Loss
Location of Breached Information:
Backup Tapes
Private Practice
City and State:
Wilmington, NC
Business Associate Involved:
Rick Lawson, Professional Computer Services
Approx. # of Individuals Affected:
2,000
Date of Breach:
12/08/09
Type of Breach:
Hacking/IT Incident
Location of Breached Information:
Computer/Network Server/Electronic Medical Record
Kaiser Permanente Medical Care Program
State:
California
Approx. # of Individuals Affected:
15,500
Date of Breach:
12/01/09
Type of Breach:
Theft
Location of Breached Information:
Portable Electronic Device
University of California, San Francisco
State:
California
Approx. # of Individuals Affected:
7,300
Date of Breach:
11/30/09
Type of Breach:
Theft
Location of Breached Information:
Laptop
Detroit Department of Health and Wellness Promotion
State:
Michigan
Approx. # of Individuals Affected:
646
Date of Breach:
11/26/09
Type of Breach:
Theft
Location of Breached Information:
Laptop, Desktop Computer
Advocate Health Care
State:
Illinois
Approx. # of Individuals Affected:
812
Date of Breach:
11/24/09
Type of Breach:
Theft
Location of Breached Information:
Laptop
Concentra
State:
Texas
Approx. # of Individuals Affected:
900
Date of Breach:
11/19/09
Type of Breach:
Theft
Location of Breached Information:
Laptop
Children's Medical Center of Dallas
State:
Texas
Approx. # of Individuals Affected:
3,800
Date of Breach:
11/19/09
Type of Breach:
Loss
Location of Breached Information:
Portable Electronic Device
Universal American, Inc.
State:
New York
Business Associate Involved:
Democracy Data & Communications, LLC
Approx. # of Individuals Affected:
83,000
Date of Breach:
11/12/09
Type of Breach:
Incorrect Mailing
Location of Breached Information:
Postcards
Massachusetts Eye and Ear Infirmary
State:
Massachusetts
Approx. # of Individuals Affected:
1,076
Date of Breach:
11/10/09
Type of Breach:
Theft
Location of Breached Information:
Other
Kern Medical Center
State:
California
Approx. # of Individuals Affected:
596
Date of Breach:
10/31/09
Type of Breach:
Theft
Location of Breached Information:
Paper Records
Blue Cross Blue Shield Association
State:
District of Columbia
Business Associate Involved:
Service Benefits Plan Administrative Services Corp.
Approx. # of Individuals Affected:
3,400
Date of Breach:
10/26/09
Type of Breach:
Unauthorized Access
Location of Breached Information:
Mailings
Detroit Department of Health and Wellness Promotion
State:
Michigan
Approx. # of Individuals Affected:
10,000
Date of Breach:
10/22/09
Type of Breach:
Theft
Location of Breached Information:
Portable Electronic Device
The Children's Hospital of Philadelphia
State:
Pennsylvania
Approx. # of Individuals Affected:
943
Date of Breach:
10/20/09
Type of Breach:
Theft
Location of Breached Information:
Laptop
Public Employee Health Insurance Plan (Kentucky Employees' Health Plan)
State:
Kentucky
Approx. # of Individuals Affected:
676
Date of Breach:
10/20/09
Type of Breach:
Misdirected E-mail
Location of Breached Information:
Brooke Army Medical Center
State:
Texas
Approx. # of Individuals Affected:
1,000
Date of Breach:
10/16/09
Type of Breach:
Theft
Location of Breached Information:
Paper Records
Alaska Department of Health and Social Services
State:
Alaska
Approx. # of Individuals Affected:
501
Date of Breach:
10/12/09
Type of Breach:
Theft
Location of Breached Information:
Portable USB Device
Cogent Healthcare of Wisconsin, S.C.
State:
Tennessee
Business Associate Involved:
Cogent Healthcare, Inc.
Approx. # of Individuals Affected:
6,400
Date of Breach:
10/11/09
Type of Breach:
Theft
Location of Breached Information:
Laptop
Health Services for Children with Special Needs, Inc.
State:
District of Columbia
Approx. # of Individuals Affected:
3,800
Date of Breach:
10/09/09
Type of Breach:
Loss
Location of Breached Information:
Laptop
Blue Cross Blue Shield Association
State:
District of Columbia
Business Associate Involved:
Merkle Direct Marketing
Approx. # of Individuals Affected:
15,000
Date of Breach:
10/07/09
Type of Breach:
Unauthorized Access
Location of Breached Information:
Mailings
Blue Cross Blue Shield of Tennessee
State:
Tennessee
Approx. # of Individuals Affected:
500,000
Date of Breach:
10/02/09
Type of Breach:
Theft
Location of Breached Information:
Hard Drives
City of Hope National Medical Center
State:
California
Approx. # of Individuals Affected:
5,900
Date of Breach:
9/27/09
Type of Breach:
Theft
Location of Breached Information:
Laptop
Private Practice
City and State:
Torrance, CA
Approx. # of Individuals Affected:
6,145
Date of Breach:
9/27/09
Type of Breach:
Theft, Unauthorized Access
Location of Breached Information:
Desktop Computer
Private Practice
City and State:
Torrance, CA
Approx. # of Individuals Affected:
5,166
Date of Breach:
9/27/09
Type of Breach:
Theft, Unauthorized Access
Location of Breached Information:
Desktop Computer
Private Practice
City and State:
Torrance, CA
Approx. # of Individuals Affected:
5,257
Date of Breach:
9/27/09
Type of Breach:
Theft, Unauthorized Access
Location of Breached Information:
Desktop Computer
Private Practice
City and State:
Torrance, CA
Approx. # of Individuals Affected:
857
Date of Breach:
9/27/09
Type of Breach:
Theft, Unauthorized Access
Location of Breached Information:
Desktop Computer
Private Practice
City and State:
Torrance, CA
Approx. # of Individuals Affected:
952
Date of Breach:
9/27/09
Type of Breach:
Theft, Unauthorized Access
Location of Breached Information:
Desktop Computer
University of California, San Francisco
State:
California
Approx. # of Individuals Affected:
610
Date of Breach:
9/22/09
Type of Breach:
Phishing Scam
Location of Breached Information:
Mid America Kidney Stone Association, LLC
State:
Missouri
Approx. # of Individuals Affected:
1,000
Date of Breach:
9/22/09
Type of Breach:
Theft
Location of Breached Information:
Network Server
Wednesday, January 6, 2010
Happy 2010 - Data Breach du Jour
Officials at Eastern Washington University (EWU) are notifying up to 130,000 current and former students that their personal information may have been exposed in a security breach, reports the Seattle Times. The data involved includes names, Social Security numbers and dates of birth for students going back to the year 1987. Information technology staff discovered the breach during a network assessment.
The takeaway here: A good New Year's resolution should be to conduct a network assessment of your own enterprise during Q1 and if you do not have a records retention policy in place ---> get one. Keeping personal information for more than 20 years is a data breach waiting to happen.
Link
Local News Hacker may have accessed EWU student information Seattle Times Newspaper
Friday, September 25, 2009
Privacy and Security Bits and Bytes
- Do you know what your information is worth on the black market? It may just surprise you. Good piece on a new Symantec tool to let you do the calculations. See Information Security Resources - What Are You Worth On The Black Market?
- Despite all of the public flurry surrounding security breaches, and customer expectations that the information entrusted to vendors will be secure, a new survey finds that an astounding 71 percent of those companies surveyed said they still weren't making data security a top initiative in their IT budgets, even though 79 percent of them admitted that they had been hit by one or more data breaches since the PCI DSS standard was enacted in 2005. Companies Still Not Securing Customer Data - InternetNews.com.
- Companies around the world are preparing for the swine flu pandemic and putting policies and procedures in place for workers and business continuity. What, if anything, are people doing about the privacy issues that need to be addressed in that planning?
Good article, with links to resources here - Protecting Your Privacy During a Pandemic - Remember our blog posts on the demise of the Clear program? Next week, the Committee on Homeland Security is holding a hearing on "The Future of the Registered Traveler Program"
Wednesday, September 30, 2009 @ 2pm
311 Cannon House Office Building
The hearing will evaluate the recent cessation of operations by Registered Traveler (RT) providers, actions undertaken by the Transportation Security Administration (TSA), and the impact on airports. There will be a webcast of this hearing.
Should be fascinating viewing. I wonder if we'll hear anymore about whatever happened to all that data???
Friday, September 18, 2009
Federal Breach Notification Rules -- NEXT WEEK. Are you ready?
New federal breach notification rules go into effect next week for covered entities and their business associates and also for vendors of personal health records.
Covered entities (organizations subject to the HIPAA privacy rule) and their business associates must report breaches of unsecured protected health information in accordance with new rules from the Department of Health and Human Services (HHS) starting Wednesday, September 23, 2009. Unsecured protected health information is information that has not been either encrypted or destroyed in accordance with HHS standards. Note that under the rules, a covered entity may not have to report a breach of unsecured protected health information if, after conducting a risk analysis, it believes in good faith that the unauthorized recipient of the PHI would not reasonably have been able to retain it (for example, if misdirected patient correspondence is returned as undeliverable and is unopened).
The breach notification regulations require prompt notification to affected individuals, as well as to the HHS Secretary and the media in cases where a breach affects more than 500 individuals. Breaches affecting fewer than 500 individuals must be reported to the HHS Secretary on an annual basis. The regulations also require business associates of covered entities to notify the covered entity of breaches by the business associate.
The HHS regulations were developed in close consultation with the Federal Trade Commission (FTC), which has issued companion breach notification regulations that apply to vendors of personal health records and certain others not covered by HIPAA. The FTC regulations are effective September 24, 2009. The rules are identical with respect to some provisions, similar in others, and completely different in a few others. Those differences can matter because some organizations will be covered by both regulations.
Both the FTC and HHS intend for their regulations’ notices to be combined with the state-required notices, so that a consumer would receive only a single notice. The agencies’ requirements for the content of the notices are practically identical, but the regulations have many differing requirements on a wide range of topics. For example, HHS’ requirements extend to breaches of health information in all formats, including paper, whereas the FTC’s requirements extend only to health information in electronic form. Also remember, there will be different state requirements for notice, some of which (particularly in Massachusetts) will conflict with the FTC/HHS content.
Links:
Text of HHS Breach Notification Rule
Text of FTC Breach Notification Rule
Mintz Matrix of State Data Breach Notification Laws, current as of August 31, 2009