Showing posts with label data breach. Show all posts
Showing posts with label data breach. Show all posts

Monday, July 12, 2010

No Harm, No Foul; Ninth Circuit Affirms Dismissal of Data Breach Case Against The Gap

Written by Kevin McGinty

It’s a distressingly common scenario. A corporate laptop containing job applicant data, including social security numbers, is stolen from an employee who has taken the laptop off of corporate premises. Access to the social security numbers makes it possible for wrongdoers to engage in identity theft. Is an applicant’s fear that data will be misused enough to support claims for negligence and breach of contract against the company? The federal Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals has joined a growing number of courts in answering that question in the negative. In Ruiz v. Gap, Inc., the court held that California law requires actual damages to support claims for negligence and breach of contract, and that time and effort that the applicant allegedly expended to monitor for identity theft were insufficient to constitute actual damages. The court reached similar conclusions as to the claim under California’s consumer protection statute and, significantly, the claim for invasion of privacy. As to the latter, the court ruled that increased threat of a breach of privacy does not constitute an actual invasion of privacy.

None of this is to say that a company is immune from state law liability and can simply elect to do nothing when a data breach occurs. Although not detailed in the Ninth Circuit’s decision, The Gap took affirmative steps to protect applicants from potential harm arising from theft of their data. Not only did The Gap notify the applicants about the theft of the computer containing their personal information, but it also offered to provide twelve months of credit monitoring and fraud assistance without charge, plus $50,000 worth of identity theft insurance. The lesson of the Ruiz decision is that companies that do take reasonable steps to mitigate against potential misuse of stolen data will have a strong defense against further liability. It also reinforces the commonsense proposition that has bedeviled many attempts to parlay data breaches into class actions – the mere threat of bad consequences is not the same as actually suffering bad consequences. Thieves generally steal computers because they want the hardware, not the data. The loss of a computer containing personal data does not inevitably mean that such data will be misused. As such, claims arising from data breaches are unlikely to succeed unless there has also been identity theft and resulting adverse consequences for individuals whose identities have been stolen.

Thursday, July 1, 2010

Data Breaches du Jour

Information regarding the latest reports of data breaches -- common thread: it is taking a startingly long time for entities to (a) discover that they have been breached, and (b) to then take action to notify affected customers of potential compromises to personal information.

Update on Major Data Breach at California Health Insurer

Updating a previous blog post (link) from Monday, WellPoint, the country's largest health insurer, has now sent notice to 470,000 members and applicants for individual health insurance nationwide informing them of a breach to a web site used by individuals to apply for insurance and track the status of their applications. The web site system run by WellPoint subsidiary Anthem Blue Cross of California was allegedly manipulated by attorneys looking to bolster a class action lawsuit against the insurer. WellPoint indicated that although the breach may have affected 230,000 California customers as previously reported, data for other applicants could have been obtained and accessed by anyone merely by altering the URL, thus prompting the additional notices.

While initially saying that personal information was unsecure for "a relatively short period of time," WellPoint now explains that five months passed before the company learned in March that a failed security update to the Anthem web site left customers' data vulnerable.

Related Link:
http://www.govinfosecurity.com/articles.php?art_id=2690


Unencrypted Patient Information Goes Missing from NY Hospital

A New York hospital is notifying some 130,000 patients that their personal information may have been compromised. Patient information stored on seven CDs belonging to New York's Lincoln Medical and Mental Health Center was lost in transit after a hospital contractor shipped them, Bloomberg reports. The unencrypted data includes Social Security numbers, dates of birth, drivers' license numbers and procedure information. In a letter sent to victims earlier this month, the hospital suggested the CDs may have been displaced at a shipping facility and destroyed.

Yet another good example for encryption of all PHI and PI in transit.

Related Link:

http://www.businessweek.com/idg/2010-06-29/new-york-hospital-loses-data-on-130-000-via-fedex.html

Continuing Data Breach Over Eight Year Period Exposes Personal and Medical Records of Students at University of Maine Counseling Center

According to the Auburn-Lewiston Sun Journal, the University of Maine Police Department is investigating a data breach that exposed nearly 5,000 students' personal and medical information. Starting in 2002 and spanning eight years, hackers accessed the UMaine counseling center database, the Sun Journal reports. The database stored information including names, Social Security numbers and clinical information. The university has hired a company to monitor the credit of those potentially affected, though there is no indication the hacked data has been viewed or used. "This is a serious breach and we are profoundly sorry that this has happened," said a university spokesman.

Related Link:
http://www.sunjournal.com/state/story/870870

Friday, June 25, 2010

July 13 Data Security Workshop - FREE

On July 13, Mintz Levin will be joined by Sophos, Six Weight Consulting, and MFA Cornerstone Consulting to hold a free compliance workshop focused on both the gaps and overlap of Massachusetts’ data protection regulation 201 CMR 17.oo and the recent updates to federal health and medical data privacy found in the HITECH Act. We'll have an interactive hands-on workshop that will help you to address some critical questions within your organization:
  • What are my organization and business partner’s obligations?
  • What kind of information do I need to protect and how do identify it?
  • Is data encryption necessary?
  • What is a WISP?
  • What is a data breach and what is my responsibility and liability if I have one?

    For information or to register to attend the event, which will be hosted by Mintz Levin in our downtown Boston office, please click this link: http://tinyurl.com/35pk3yr

Thursday, June 24, 2010

Twitter Settles With FTC

Twitter has reached a settlement with the Federal Trade Commission (FTC) over charges that it “deceived consumers and put their privacy at risk by failing to safeguard their personal information.” In the Matter of Twitter, Inc.,

The FTC had alleged that “serious lapses” in Twitter’s security last year "allowed hackers to obtain administrative control of Twitter, including access to tweets that consumers had designated private, and the ability to send out phony tweets pretending to be from then-President-elect Barack Obama and Fox News, among others." The two incidents mentioned involved hackers using password-guessing tools to gain access to administrative functions. Under the settlement, Twitter must maintain a comprehensive information security program, to be assessed by a third-party every other year for 10 years. It also will be prohibited from misleading consumers about the extent to which it maintains and protects the security, privacy and confidentiality of nonpublic consumer information.
Related links:

Twitter Settles Charges that it Failed to Protect Consumers' Personal Information; Company Will Establish Independently Audited Information Security Program

Twitter settles with US regulators over privacy breach - Yahoo! News

Twitter settles with FTC for privacy breach Forrester Blogs

Friday, April 30, 2010

Privacy and Security Bits and Bytes

On this last day of April, there are a couple of breaches and another clarion warning about copy machines --


We have blogged on this issue here and here -- and again, there is another warning about the treasure trove of information residing on the hard drive of your copy machine. A CBS Evening News investigation revealed just how much information is stored on copy machines that gets passed on when the machine’s lease is up and the machine is resold. Adding one more to the mounting pile of privacy-related investigation requests the Federal Trade Commission has received in recent days, U.S. Rep. Edward Markey (D-MA) requested the commission look into the issue in a statement released yesterday.

Make sure that you don’t violate data protection laws in Guernsey – the offshore banking center has amended its privacy law to include prison time for violations. Persons found guilty under Section 55 of the law of unlawfully obtaining (or disclosing) personal data without the consent of the data controller may now face a prison sentence. Previously, the most severe penalty available was a fine of up to £10,000 Data protection law amended - International Law Office

Add Mexico to the list of countries with a national comprehensive data protection law. Mexico's Senate on Tuesday unanimously approved the Federal Law of Protection of Personal Information. The law establishes the rights and principles of data protection in the private sector, and was nine years in the making.

And two “breaches du jour”: The Louisville Courier-Journal reports that a flash drive containing the personal information of 24,600 patients of a psychiatric hospital has gone missing. According to the report, the drive contained patient names, admission and discharge dates and dates of birth. (Begs the question of why protected health information (or PHI) is on an unsecured flash drive in the first place…. ) And, in California, St. Jude Heritage Healthcare has notified 22,000 patients about the theft of five hospital computers containing their PHI.

Friday, April 9, 2010

Privacy and Security Bits and Bytes

Our Friday afternoon feature --

Virginia Adds Medical Information Breach Law - The Commonwealth of Virginia has amended its data breach notification law to include breaches of medical information. For the text of the amendment, link here. Even if the data is encrypted, the law requires notice if the breach involved a person with access to the encryption key. The law requires notice to affected individuals (residents of Virginia) as well as Virginia's Office of Attorney General. The Attorney General can bring an action for violations of the law and impose civil penalties up to $150,000 per breach (or a series of similar breaches of a similar nature that are discovered in a single investigation). The law does not apply to persons or entities that must report the breach under the HITECH Act.

“Data Security – It’s a Responsibility, Not an Option” – interesting point of view from InfoSecIsland.


FTC Complaint Focuses on Tracking, Profiling of Consumers. -- Yesterday, the Center for Digital Democracy, the US Public Interest Research Group, and the World Privacy Forum filed a complaint with the FTC regarding two emerging trends in online advertising that they say pose growing threats to consumer privacy: auctioning of individual Internet users for targeted advertising opportunities and the combination of online and offline data about Internet users. The complaint describes what the group feels is a growing trend in online behavioral advertising that involves the real-time sale and trade of the right to target individual users with online ads through the use of data compiled about users via their Web surfing habits. The groups have asked the FTC to investigate the data and advertising exchanges operated by Google, Microsoft and Yahoo, as well as several firms that support the auctioning and data collection/targeting system, including AppNexus, BlueKai and Rubicon Project. Furthermore, the group has asked the FTC to require the firms involved in real-time online tracking and auction bidding to allow consumers to opt-in to participate in such activities; require firms to update their privacy policies so consumers are aware of these activities; and ensure consumers are compensated for the use of their data. Stay tuned.

Large UK Data Breach Penalty Takes Effect -- As we warned you in this space last month, this week marks the effective date of the new, substantially higher fines in the UK for data loss. Reports are that up to 65 percent of workers are unaware of the new penalties – which can quickly hit £500K for large scale breaches. If you’re operating in the UK, check out Data loss fines hit £500K from today • The Register or ICO vows to impose heavy fines for major data breaches - 07 Apr 2010 - Computing.

And Finally --

This item from Wired Magazine proves yet again that identity theft is not limited to computer hacking or interception of electronic messages. A 74-count indictment unsealed yesterday in Arizona details charges that a group of sophisticated identity thieves managed to steal millions of dollars by filing bogus tax returns using the names and Social Security numbers of other people, many of them deceased.

Tuesday, March 30, 2010

Government "Outs" Mystery Retailers in Gonzalez Hack Case

Interesting post in today’s Wired: Threat Level blog about a motion in the Alberto Gonzalez hacking case that was unsealed on Monday. We now have the identities of the other two “mystery” retailers – J.C. Penney was “Company A” and Wet Seal was “Company B.”

J.C. Penney argued unsuccessfully last week to keep the company’s identity under seal, and that it (a corporation) was entitled to anonymity under the 2004 Crime Victims' Rights Act. That law was intended to protect the “dignity and privacy” of victims – and that is what Penney argued. but Judge Douglas P. Woodcock was not convinced -- and in fact was "astonished." The Judge said in the hearing that he believed both retailers should have announced their involvement from the start and that consumers had the right to know. Woodlock said he would not provide the companies “insulation from transparency.”

For more: StorefrontBacktalk » JC Penney, Wet Seal: Gonzalez Mystery Merchants

Motion of Government - http://www.wired.com/images_blogs/threatlevel/2010/03/09-cr-10382-14.pdf

Friday, March 26, 2010

Restaurant Chain Settles FTC Data Breach Charges

Yesterday, the Federal Trade Commission (“FTC”) weighed in with another proposed settlement agreement requiring that the Dave & Buster's restaurant chain that experienced a massive data breach in 2007 establish and maintain a comprehensive information security program as a condition of settling a consumer protection action arising out of that data breach.

This is the FTC’s 27th case challenging faulty data security practices by organizations that handle sensitive consumer information.

Our Client Alert with complete links to the draft order and complaint and full discussion will be posted later today.

Wednesday, March 24, 2010

Quick Compliance Survey

No, we're not "taking names" here. This is just a 10-question survey to gauge some basic compliance metrics. Please participate!

Click here to take survey

Thursday, March 4, 2010

Major "goof" at Citibank

For all of you who have been struggling with data security compliance obligations from various fronts, and trying to handle complex technical issues such as encryption of portable devices and data "at rest" and "in transit" --- here is a very big story regarding plain old everyday mail. If you are a Citibank customer, Citi may have printed your Social Security number on the outside of an envelope that it has sent to you ..... and about 600,000 other customers.

Check this out at WalletPop

Tuesday, March 2, 2010

Hotel Chain Hacked Again....

Wyndham Hotels and Resorts has apparently notified the U.S. Secret Service and several state attorneys that hackers stole customer names and payment card information from its computer system. Wyndham has since notified credit card companies so that affected cardholders' accounts may be monitored. It also has hired a firm to investigate the breach and assist in data security improvements. This is the company's third data breach in one year.

Related Links
Letter posted to Wyndham website
V3 UK - Wyndham Hotel Chain Hacked Again

Friday, January 15, 2010

Connecticut Attorney General Brings Charges Against Health Net for HIPAA Violations

Written by Dianne Bourque

On January 13, Connecticut Attorney General Richard Blumenthal filed charges against Health Net of Connecticut, Inc., for violating federal privacy law. Blumenthal is the first state attorney general to file such a suit using HIPAA enforcement authority granted to states under the HITECH provisions of the American Recovery and Reinvestment Act of 2009.

The law suit was prompted by Health Net’s loss of a portable disk drive from a Connecticut office. The unencrypted drive contained health and other personal information for approximately 1.5 million current and former Health Net members. Almost one-half million of the affected members were Connecticut residents.

In a statement, Health Net said that it would cooperate with the Attorney General and that there is no evidence that any of the lost data had been misused.

Monday, January 11, 2010

New Settlement Agreement in Heartland Breach

And the cash register continues to ring with respect to the Heartland Payment Systems Inc. breach.

Heartland disclosed last week in a filing with the Securities and Exchange Commission that it has agreed to pay a maximum of $60 million to Visa Inc. and Visa card-issuing banks to settle claims arising out of the massive payment card data breach last January.

The proposed settlement is conditioned on 80% of eligible banks accepting the settlement offers. Under the agreement, some $59.2 million of the maximum settlement amount would be available to pay Visa card-issuing banks for their costs associated with the data breach. An additional $780,000 would be used to clear fines related to the breach collected by Visa from banks. According to the agreement, settlement offers will go out to eligible Visa-issuing banks next week and must be accepted by January 29.

More information: The full text of the Settlement Agreement

Wednesday, January 6, 2010

Happy 2010 - Data Breach du Jour

We are just barely into the new year, and there is already a rather large data breach to report.

Officials at Eastern Washington University (EWU) are notifying up to 130,000 current and former students that their personal information may have been exposed in a security breach, reports the Seattle Times. The data involved includes names, Social Security numbers and dates of birth for students going back to the year 1987. Information technology staff discovered the breach during a network assessment.

The takeaway here: A good New Year's resolution should be to conduct a network assessment of your own enterprise during Q1 and if you do not have a records retention policy in place ---> get one. Keeping personal information for more than 20 years is a data breach waiting to happen.

Link
Local News Hacker may have accessed EWU student information Seattle Times Newspaper

Monday, December 21, 2009

The real cost of data breaches - Heartland to pay Amex $3.5 million

According to its 8-K filing with the Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC), Heartland Payment Systems Inc. has agreed to pay American Express Travel Related Services Co. Inc. just over $3.5 million to settle any claims arising out of a massive payment card data breach.

This settlement is likely to be only the first over the compromise of tens of millions of debit
and credit card accounts by malicious software planted on Heartland's computers
that the Princeton, N.J.-based payment card processor revealed in January of this year.

On November 12, Heartland filed a Form 8-K with the SEC, stating that it had doubled from $35.6 million to $73.3 million its anticipated breach expenses for 2009, because it expected to settle litigation related to the breach.

Heartland faced a total of 17 consumer class actions and 10 bank and credit union class actions related to the breach, which were consolidated in the U.S. District Court for the Southern District of Texas. According to the Form 8-K filing, the newly announced settlement agreement
would release Heartland from any claims raised by AmEx or its issuing banks. The filing did not indicate whether the settlement is subject to court approval and did not include a copy of the agreement.

Tuesday, November 3, 2009

Privacy Class Actions....Waiting for Hannaford

My colleague, Kevin McGinty, has penned an interesting analysis of the latest in the class action litigation arising out of the Hannaford supermarket chain data breach.

Specifically, Maine’s highest court is being asked to determine whether the law recognizes the time and effort payment cardholders spend trying to protect themselves after a data breach as a “substantial injury” for which they can be compensated. Kevin analyzes how the Maine Supreme Court's decision could affect the protections that zero-liability programs afford retailers involved in data breaches because consumers do not experience actual out-of-pocket damages.

Links:

Mintz Levin Privacy and Class Action Alert
Motion to Dismiss
Complaint

Wednesday, October 7, 2009

More on the real cost of the Heartland breach

Nearly 10 months after disclosing a months-long data breach that affected millions of consumers, the financial impact of the Heartland data breach continues to unfold. InformationWeek reports that Heartland stock prices plunged more than $500 million following the breach, and while shareholder value has rebounded, other breach related costs have thus far totaled $32 million, with numerous lawsuits against the company still pending.

Tuesday, October 6, 2009

Vets Data At Risk? Again?

Wired.com reports on a possible breach at -- of all places -- the National Archives and Records Administration (NARA) that, if verified, could affect tens of millions of records about U.S. military veterans. It appears that it may involve an issue that I call “Data Security 101” -- the failure of a contractor to wipe clean a defective hard drive returned to it by NARA . The contractor determined that the drive could not be fixed, and sent it elsewhere to be recycled --- without following ordinary industry procedures (and U.S. Government policy) requiring that hard drives be degaussed before recycling or other disposition.

According to the Wired piece, the incident was reported to NARA’s inspector general by Hank Bellomy, a NARA IT manager, “who charges that the move put 70 million veterans at risk of identity theft, and that NARA’s practice of returning hard drives unsanitized was symptomatic of an irresponsible security mindset unbecoming to America’s record-keeping agency.”

The Veterans Administration settled a class action earlier this year at a cost of $20 million over the 2006 loss of a laptop containing records with personal information of up to 26.5 million veterans and active duty personnel.

Friday, September 25, 2009

Privacy and Security Bits and Bytes

After a bit of a hiatus, our Friday afternoon feature is back:

  • Do you know what your information is worth on the black market? It may just surprise you. Good piece on a new Symantec tool to let you do the calculations. See Information Security Resources - What Are You Worth On The Black Market?
  • Despite all of the public flurry surrounding security breaches, and customer expectations that the information entrusted to vendors will be secure, a new survey finds that an astounding 71 percent of those companies surveyed said they still weren't making data security a top initiative in their IT budgets, even though 79 percent of them admitted that they had been hit by one or more data breaches since the PCI DSS standard was enacted in 2005. Companies Still Not Securing Customer Data - InternetNews.com.
  • Companies around the world are preparing for the swine flu pandemic and putting policies and procedures in place for workers and business continuity. What, if anything, are people doing about the privacy issues that need to be addressed in that planning?
    Good article, with links to resources here - Protecting Your Privacy During a Pandemic
  • Remember our blog posts on the demise of the Clear program? Next week, the Committee on Homeland Security is holding a hearing on "The Future of the Registered Traveler Program"
    Wednesday, September 30, 2009 @ 2pm
    311 Cannon House Office Building
    The hearing will evaluate the recent cessation of operations by Registered Traveler (RT) providers, actions undertaken by the Transportation Security Administration (TSA), and the impact on airports. There will be a webcast of this hearing.

Should be fascinating viewing. I wonder if we'll hear anymore about whatever happened to all that data???

Friday, September 18, 2009

Federal Breach Notification Rules -- NEXT WEEK. Are you ready?

Written by Cynthia and Dianne

New federal breach notification rules go into effect next week for covered entities and their business associates and also for vendors of personal health records.

Covered entities (organizations subject to the HIPAA privacy rule) and their business associates must report breaches of unsecured protected health information in accordance with new rules from the Department of Health and Human Services (HHS) starting Wednesday, September 23, 2009. Unsecured protected health information is information that has not been either encrypted or destroyed in accordance with HHS standards. Note that under the rules, a covered entity may not have to report a breach of unsecured protected health information if, after conducting a risk analysis, it believes in good faith that the unauthorized recipient of the PHI would not reasonably have been able to retain it (for example, if misdirected patient correspondence is returned as undeliverable and is unopened).

The breach notification regulations require prompt notification to affected individuals, as well as to the HHS Secretary and the media in cases where a breach affects more than 500 individuals. Breaches affecting fewer than 500 individuals must be reported to the HHS Secretary on an annual basis. The regulations also require business associates of covered entities to notify the covered entity of breaches by the business associate.

The HHS regulations were developed in close consultation with the Federal Trade Commission (FTC), which has issued companion breach notification regulations that apply to vendors of personal health records and certain others not covered by HIPAA. The FTC regulations are effective September 24, 2009. The rules are identical with respect to some provisions, similar in others, and completely different in a few others. Those differences can matter because some organizations will be covered by both regulations.

Both the FTC and HHS intend for their regulations’ notices to be combined with the state-required notices, so that a consumer would receive only a single notice. The agencies’ requirements for the content of the notices are practically identical, but the regulations have many differing requirements on a wide range of topics. For example, HHS’ requirements extend to breaches of health information in all formats, including paper, whereas the FTC’s requirements extend only to health information in electronic form. Also remember, there will be different state requirements for notice, some of which (particularly in Massachusetts) will conflict with the FTC/HHS content.

Links:
Text of HHS Breach Notification Rule
Text of FTC Breach Notification Rule
Mintz Matrix of State Data Breach Notification Laws, current as of August 31, 2009