Tuesday, June 29, 2010

Latest Postponements and Exemptions of FTC Enforcement of ‘Red Flags’ Rule

Written by Kenneth Gantz

At the urging of congressional lawmakers, the Federal Trade Commission has for the fifth time delayed enforcement of the “Red Flags” Rule – this time through December 31, 2010. In the interim, Congress plans to consider legislation that would alter the scope of entities covered under the Rule.

Under the Fair and Accurate Credit Transactions Act, Congress directed the FTC and other agencies to develop regulations requiring financial institutions and creditors to address the risk of identity theft. The FTC in turn sought to impose the Red Flags Rule, requiring all such entities to develop and implement written identity theft prevention programs.

In a news release issued on the organization’s website, “[the FTC] urges Congress to act quickly to pass legislation that will resolve any questions as to which entities are covered by the Rule and obviate the need for further enforcement delays.” The Commission goes on to explain that it will begin enforcement sooner should Congress pass legislation limiting the scope of the Red Flags Rule with an effective date earlier than December 31, 2010.

Additionally, the FTC agreed on June 25 to temporarily exempt physicians from the Red Flags Rule. Per a joint stipulation with the American Medical Association and other health organizations, the FTC will wait until the U.S. Court of Appeals for the District of Columbia resolves questions concerning the Rule’s scope before it seeks enforcement against physicians. The AMA, American Osteopathic Association, and the Medical Society of the District of Columbia had filed a lawsuit on May 21 to prevent the FTC from applying the rule to physicians (AMA v. FTC, D.D.C., No. 1:10-cv-00843), arguing that the FTC exceeded its statutory powers and acted in a manner that is “arbitrary, capricious, and contrary to the law.”

The District Court previously barred the FTC from applying the Red Flags Rule to attorneys following a similar challenge by the American Bar Association. The FTC appealed that decision, and the health group’s lawsuit will now be put on hold until the Court of Appeals issues its opinion in the ABA case.

Related Links:
http://www.ftc.gov/opa/2010/05/redflags.shtm

http://www.healthdatamanagement.com/news/red-flags-rule-identity-theft-lawsuit-physicians-40572-1.html

http://www.ama-assn.org/ama1/pub/upload/mm/395/red-flags-lawsuit.pdf (AMA’s complaint)

Monday, June 28, 2010

Major Data Breach at California Health Insurer

Written by Kenneth Gantz

Anthem Blue Cross is notifying approximately 230,000 members and applicants for individual health insurance of a breach involving a web site used by individuals to apply for insurance and track the status of their applications. Anthem claims that attorneys managed to manipulate the web address within the web site in order to obtain information in support of a class action lawsuit against the insurer.

The attorneys were apparently able to access medical information in addition to Social Security and credit card numbers, resulting from a failure to reinstate security mechanisms following an October 2009 upgrade to the web site.As part of a statement issued by the company, Anthem offered the following: "The ability to manipulate the web address (URL) was available for a relatively short period of time following an upgrade to the system. After the upgrade was completed, a third party vendor validated that discovered, we made the necessary security changes to prevent it from happening again."We have requested both by letter and in court filings that the attorneys return all information improperly obtained from the individual application system and as a result, that information has been delivered to a court approved custodian who will ensure its security.”

Interestingly, Anthem said that “out of an abundance of caution” it is providing a detailed notification explaining what happened to individuals who might be affected by the breach, but apparently no legal obligation from its point of view. California law requires that affected residents be notified of breaches of health information. See http://www.mintz.com/newsletter/2007/PrivSec-DataBreachLaws-02-07/state_data_breach_matrix.pdf. The insurer will also offer notified individuals a year of free identity protection services. Meanwhile, Anthem is weighing legal action it might take “with respect to the data, the impact—if any—on our members, and the remediation costs incurred as a result of these actions.”

Related Links:http://www.insurancenetworking.com/news/health_insurance_technology_Anthem_Blue_Cross_data_security_risk-25114-1.html

Friday, June 25, 2010

July 13 Data Security Workshop - FREE

On July 13, Mintz Levin will be joined by Sophos, Six Weight Consulting, and MFA Cornerstone Consulting to hold a free compliance workshop focused on both the gaps and overlap of Massachusetts’ data protection regulation 201 CMR 17.oo and the recent updates to federal health and medical data privacy found in the HITECH Act. We'll have an interactive hands-on workshop that will help you to address some critical questions within your organization:
  • What are my organization and business partner’s obligations?
  • What kind of information do I need to protect and how do identify it?
  • Is data encryption necessary?
  • What is a WISP?
  • What is a data breach and what is my responsibility and liability if I have one?

    For information or to register to attend the event, which will be hosted by Mintz Levin in our downtown Boston office, please click this link: http://tinyurl.com/35pk3yr

Thursday, June 24, 2010

Twitter Settles With FTC

Twitter has reached a settlement with the Federal Trade Commission (FTC) over charges that it “deceived consumers and put their privacy at risk by failing to safeguard their personal information.” In the Matter of Twitter, Inc.,

The FTC had alleged that “serious lapses” in Twitter’s security last year "allowed hackers to obtain administrative control of Twitter, including access to tweets that consumers had designated private, and the ability to send out phony tweets pretending to be from then-President-elect Barack Obama and Fox News, among others." The two incidents mentioned involved hackers using password-guessing tools to gain access to administrative functions. Under the settlement, Twitter must maintain a comprehensive information security program, to be assessed by a third-party every other year for 10 years. It also will be prohibited from misleading consumers about the extent to which it maintains and protects the security, privacy and confidentiality of nonpublic consumer information.
Related links:

Twitter Settles Charges that it Failed to Protect Consumers' Personal Information; Company Will Establish Independently Audited Information Security Program

Twitter settles with US regulators over privacy breach - Yahoo! News

Twitter settles with FTC for privacy breach Forrester Blogs

Tuesday, June 22, 2010

FTC Highlights Need for Privacy and Security in Internet Commerce

Written by Jillian Collins

The Federal Trade Commission has weighed in as part of the Department of Commerce's public comment process on privacy and security issues. According to the FTC's comment, consumers trusting that their personal information will be safeguarded is essential to the success of e-commerce, and innovation is essential to ensuring privacy in the fast-paced, ever-changing world of the Internet economy. The topic of innovation and internet privacy controls has been, and continues to be, one of the FTC’s "highest consumer protection priorities for more than a decade," according to the comment.

In the comment, the FTC laid out several aspects of its privacy program. The agency led nearly 30 enforcement cases challenging business practices that allegedly failed to secure consumers' personal information and made efforts at educating consumers and businesses about privacy and security in an online world. The FTC also has several policy initiatives including promoting self-regulation in online behavioral advertising and participates in international privacy programs. The agency hosted several privacy roundtables and plans to public privacy and security proposals for public comment later this year.

Related links:
http://www.ftc.gov/opa/2010/06/foodinternet.shtm

The Google Payload Data Fallout Continues

Written by Jillian Collins

Connecticut Attorney General Richard Blumenthal says he will lead a multistate investigation into Google Street View cars’ unauthorized collection of personal data from WiFi networks. The Connecticut AG said he expects a significant number of states to participate. More than 30 states participated in a recent conference call regarding the Connecticut investigation.
In a statement released yesterday, Blumenthal called Google’s data collection a “deeply disturbing invasion of personal privacy,” and said that consumers have a right to know what personal information, including potentially emails, web browsing habits and passwords, Google may have collected. “Google must come clean, explaining how and why it intercepted and saved private information broadcast over personal and business wireless networks,” he said. Google maintains that it did not collect the payload data intentionally and never used it , but the company may be facing not only domestic consequences but also investigations in the UK and other affected countries. Google says it stopped collecting Wi-Fi data from its Street View vehicles when it discovered the data collection problem last month following an inquiry by German regulators. The Google payload data incident is just one recent PR problem related to privacy concerns for the internet giant. Google took harsh criticism for the launch of Buzz because the feature initially revealed information about the names of users' email contacts. Google has significantly revised the service; now, it merely suggests followers, rather than automatically creating them.

Related links:http://www.mediapost.com/publications/?fa=Articles.showArticle&art_aid=130619http://www.foxnews.com/world/2010/06/22/uk-police-investigating-alleged-google-privacy-breach-public-wi-fi-networks/

More on Supreme Court Ruling in Quon

And as promised in our last post, here is the latest Client Advisory on the Supreme Court's ruling in the Quon case.

Thursday, June 17, 2010

Breaking News: Supreme Court Issues Decision in Employee Privacy Case

Written by Martha Zackin

As we’ve blogged in this space,, back in December, the Supreme Court agreed to hear City of Onatario v. Quon, a case on the privacy of text messages sent by a government employee on employer-provided devices. Specifically, the Court agreed to consider whether a police sergeant assigned to a Ontario, California SWAT team had a reasonable expectation of privacy under the Fourth Amendment in sexually-explicit, non-work related text messages transmitted on a department-issued pager and stored by an outside service provider even in the face of the City’s "general practice" of non-monitoring of such communications.

Today, the Court issued its opinion, finding that the City’s search of Sergeant Quon’s text messages to his colleagues and the woman with whom he was having an affair was reasonable. Although the Court did not reach agreement on whether and to what extent government workers have any reasonable expectation of privacy in communications such as those at issue here, the Court did agree that the search was reasonable.

The impact of this decision may be limited to Sergeant Quon and his co-workers; the Court explicitly cautioned against using the facts of the case to establish “far-reaching premises that define the existence, and extent, of privacy expectations enjoyed by employees when using employer-provided communication devices.”

More to come.

Wednesday, May 26, 2010

Congressmen Question Google on Wi-Fi

Today, Congressmen Joe Barton (R-TX), Edward Markey (D-MA), and Henry Waxman (D-CA)wrote to Google Chairman and CEO Eric Schmidt seeking answers to the company’s collection of private information over Wi-Fi networks.

“We are concerned that Google did not disclose until long after the fact that consumers’ Internet use was being recorded, analyzed and perhaps profiled. In addition, we are concerned about the completeness and accuracy of Google’s public explanations about this matter,” wrote the lawmakers. “For example, on April 27, 2010, a Google blog post contained inaccurate information about whether payload data was collected. However, a Google executive on May 14, 2010, admitted in Google’s official blog that the company had ‘been mistakenly collecting samples of payload data from open (i.e., non-password-protected) Wi-Fi networks.’”

Barton and Markey, co-chairmen of the House Privacy Caucus, separately wrote last week to Federal Trade Commission Chairman Jon Liebowitz about Google’s recent revelation that it gathered the network information.

The lawmakers asked Schmidt to respond to the following questions:

What percentage of United States roads have been documented for Google Street View?

Over what time period did the collection of information for Google Street View take place or, if roads are visited by Google Street View vehicles more than once, what is the schedule for return visits to roads?

Have all Street View vehicles documenting United States roads been engaged in the monitoring or data collection of Wi-Fi transmissions at all times during those activities? If the answer is no, please explain in detail in what communities the monitoring or data collection was conducted and the reasons that these communities were chosen for monitoring or data collection.

How many Wi-Fi networks across the country have been logged since Google began its Street View program? How many consumers were subject to the data collection?

Was any notification of this monitoring and data collection made to affected communities prior to deploying Street View vehicles, and was consent sought from consumers? If so, please explain the notice and consent procedures involved. If not, please explain why this was not done.

Has Google at any time conducted a legal analysis regarding the applicability of consumer privacy laws on the monitoring and data collection of Wi-Fi transmissions? If so, please provide a copy of this analysis.

Please explain why Google chose to collect the data and how it intended to use the data.

What is the status of the consumer data collected? Has it been analyzed and used in any way? Does Google have plans to use it in the future? Please explain in detail.

Has the collected data been destroyed? If yes, when and by which method(s)? If not, why not?

What is the status of Google’s internal review of Street View’s monitoring and data collection practices to ensure adequate controls? What is the methodology? When did the review start? Who is conducting the review? Are there any interim findings? When is it expected to be completed? Will the review, or portions of it, be made available to the public?

What is Google’s process to ensure that data collection associated with new products and services offered by the company is adequately controlled?

Has Google asked a third party to review the software at issue? If so, who is the third party, and what is the nature of the review?

A copy of the letter to Schmidt can be found here. A copy of the letter to the FTC on the Google can be found here.

Monday, May 24, 2010

Red Flags Rule Compliance Date Approaching - American Medical Association Sues

It’s been a while since we have visited the Federal Trade Commission’s Red Flags Rule here in this blog. The oft-postponed deadline is now fast approaching on June 1. Except, that is, for lawyers and now, doctors.

On Friday, the American Medical Association filed a lawsuit against the FTC for defining physicians as “creditors” and claiming that requiring physicians to comply with the Red Flags Rule could jeopardize the doctor-patient confidential relationship. The Red Flags Rule (to refresh your memory) requires that “creditors” establish identity theft protection programs and would likely require physicians to obtain positive identification of patient identity – before providing treatment, as argued by the AMA.

The lawsuit argues that the FTC acted beyond its authority because physicians are not creditors and patients are neither accountholders nor customers under the Fair and Accurate Credit Transactions Act (FACTA). The latter is a more likely argument than the former. Under FACTA, an “entity that regularly defers payment for goods or services” can be considered to be a creditor and physicians routinely bill patients after the completion of services, including for the remainder of medical fees not reimbursed by insurance. I have been in doctor’s offices over the last 6 months where new patients are asked for their insurance card, and their driver’s license or a photo ID. This would seem to be a small step towards controlling medical identity theft.

Read about medical identity theft at World Privacy Forum Medical Identity Theft Page

Thursday, May 13, 2010

Facebook Holding Privacy Summit

As a follow-on to yesterday's posts regarding the public face of the Facebook privacy brouhaha, at this hour Facebook is holding an “all-hands” meeting to discuss the company’s overall privacy strategy. PC World suggests that perhaps today’s company meeting is the beginning of Facebook's effort to improve user guidance on issues of sharing and privacy, or maybe the company is considering a roll back of new features. Stay tuned.

Related links:

GigaOM » Facebook Needs to Find Its Voice on Privacy
Facebook's Eroding Privacy Policy: A Timeline Electronic Frontier Foundation

Wednesday, May 12, 2010

The back-and-forth on Facebook's privacy travails

Whether the terse discussions in the public arena over Facebook’s privacy “changes” demonstrate that the world’s largest social network is playing fast and loose with the truth about its internal controls on user privacy, or whether it is just an example of poor corporate communication of policies to end users is still a matter of debate. See Glitch Brings New Worries About Facebook’s Privacy - NYTimes.com.

Last week, the author of the Times’ technology blog Bits invited readers to submit questions for Facebook's vice president for public policy, Elliot Schrage. She probably got more than she (or Schrage) expected – in fact, over 300 of them. Schrage’s response is published in today’s blog entry: Facebook Executive Answers Reader Questions - Bits Blog - NYTimes.com.

For a completely different view of Mr. Schrage’s comments, I found Catharine Taylor’s post at Social Media Insider to raise some important questions.

Two privacy issues from North of the Border

Ann Cavoukian, Ontario’s information and privacy commissioner, has issued her 2009 Annual Report, entitled “Access & Privacy, A Time for Innovation.” One of Cavoukian’s main subjects this year is the smart grid and the associated privacy issues, including the collection of knowledge about personal habits via “smart” appliances communicating with the grid. Cavoukian is a thought leader in building privacy into processes and controls and we’ve blogged about some of her writings in past issues. Her latest publication is worth consideration as we move further along with technological development – and before the grid becomes too smart.

Related link:
Smart grid data must be protected: Privacy czar - thestar.com

And, Canada’s Assistant Privacy Commissioner is expressing concerns about the U.S. Secure Flight Program that will complete implementation and be fully operational by December. Under the program, passengers of any nationality who raise suspicions of U.S. authorities can be prevented from boarding flights that fly over U.S. airspace. Chantal Bernier told the Canadian Parliament yesterday that there is little Canada can do about it except urge the U.S. government to address extremely long data retention periods and other privacy concerns of Canadians. Under the program, Homeland Security may retain information collected (including name, birth date, flight information, itinerary and passport number) for periods ranging from a week up to 99 years.

Related link:
Vancouver Sun

Thursday, May 6, 2010

Privacy Events Calendar

Symposium on Privacy and Innovation

Tomorrow
, the Commerce Department is hosting a day-long symposium called “A Dialogue on Privacy and Innovation.” It will include several panel discussions to discuss stakeholder views and to facilitate further public discussion on privacy policy in the United States. The event will seek participation and comment from all Internet stakeholders, including the commercial, academic, and civil society sectors, on the impact of current privacy laws in the United States and around the world on the pace of innovation in the information economy. The event will be webcast at
http://www.ntia.doc.gov/InternetPolicyTaskForce/privacy/webcast.html

This Symposium is related to Commerce’s ongoing Notice of Inquiry seeking comment on the impact of current privacy laws in the United States and around the world on the pace of innovation in the internet economy. The Notice of Inquiry is at Internet Policy Task Force and comments are due June 7, 2010.


Roundtable on COPPA

FTC has announced that it will host a public roundtable on June 2, 2010, to examine whether technology changes warrant revisions to the Children’s Online Privacy Protection Rule. The Rule was enacted in 2000 and requires website operators to obtain parental consent before collecting, using, or disclosing personal information from children under the age of 13. Topics will include whether the Rule should be applied to emerging media, a potential expansion of the Rule to cover additional types of information, and the review of the verification methods used by websites. The roundtable will be held at the FTC Conference Center at 601 New Jersey Avenue, NW in Washington, DC. It is free and open to the public. No advanced registration is required

20th Annual CFP Conference

The 20th Conference on Computers, Freedom, and Privacy will be held on June 15-18 in San Jose, CA. Keynote speakers include Peter Cullen of Microsoft and David Drummond of Google. "Hot topics" sessions covering the latest news in freedom, privacy, and networks, and CFP's first "Unconference". Other highlights include sessions focusing on consumer advocacy, human rights, business perspectives, and cutting-edge intersections between technology and policy.

Monday, May 3, 2010

Welcome to the Privacy Revolution

This is "Choose Privacy Week" – an initiative by the American Library Association to raise awareness about sharing information online. The Association has launched a new website, Privacy Revolution, offering tips for educators and parents on ways to address privacy concerns with children.

One sure way not to raise the issue was demonstrated by a principal in Ridgewood, New Jersey last week. According to a post by Christopher Dawson in ZDNet Education IT, principal Anthony Orsini sent parents an email strongly urging them to take the role of cyberpolice with their middle school children, because “…there is absolutely, positively no reason for any middle school student to be a part of a social networking site! None.” Raising the consciousness of parents to the risks and dangers inherent in social networking and encouraging discussion at home is one thing. This is on an entirely different level.

Related links:
New Jersey principal deputizes parents as cyber police Education IT ZDNet.comALA Launches Choose Privacy Week - 5/3/2010 - School Library Journal

Sunday, May 2, 2010

OT -- Emergency Response 2.0 : Solutions to Respond to Oil Spill in the Gulf of Mexico

Off the privacy topic, but certainly an issue of national security. Mintz Levin client, InnoCentive, is crowdsourcing a solution to respond to the oil spill in the Gulf of Mexico. Over 250 people are currently working on the challenge posted to the site (link below) -- pass this on and get the collective wisdoms of the crowd moving!!

Emergency Response 2.0 : Solutions to Respond to Oil Spill in the Gulf of Mexico

Friday, April 30, 2010

Privacy and Security Bits and Bytes

On this last day of April, there are a couple of breaches and another clarion warning about copy machines --


We have blogged on this issue here and here -- and again, there is another warning about the treasure trove of information residing on the hard drive of your copy machine. A CBS Evening News investigation revealed just how much information is stored on copy machines that gets passed on when the machine’s lease is up and the machine is resold. Adding one more to the mounting pile of privacy-related investigation requests the Federal Trade Commission has received in recent days, U.S. Rep. Edward Markey (D-MA) requested the commission look into the issue in a statement released yesterday.

Make sure that you don’t violate data protection laws in Guernsey – the offshore banking center has amended its privacy law to include prison time for violations. Persons found guilty under Section 55 of the law of unlawfully obtaining (or disclosing) personal data without the consent of the data controller may now face a prison sentence. Previously, the most severe penalty available was a fine of up to £10,000 Data protection law amended - International Law Office

Add Mexico to the list of countries with a national comprehensive data protection law. Mexico's Senate on Tuesday unanimously approved the Federal Law of Protection of Personal Information. The law establishes the rights and principles of data protection in the private sector, and was nine years in the making.

And two “breaches du jour”: The Louisville Courier-Journal reports that a flash drive containing the personal information of 24,600 patients of a psychiatric hospital has gone missing. According to the report, the drive contained patient names, admission and discharge dates and dates of birth. (Begs the question of why protected health information (or PHI) is on an unsecured flash drive in the first place…. ) And, in California, St. Jude Heritage Healthcare has notified 22,000 patients about the theft of five hospital computers containing their PHI.

Thursday, April 29, 2010

Connecticut Woman Files First Suit Under Federal Law Prohibiting Genetic Discrimination

Written by Jennifer Rubin

A Connecticut woman has filed a charge of discrimination under the Federal Genetic Information Nondiscrimination Act ("GINA"), which prohibits discrimination against employees based upon their status as carriers of genetic information. The woman claims her status as a carrier of the BRCA2 gene, a gene sometimes associated with the elevated risk of breast cancer, led to her termination after she had preventive surgery relating to her breast cancer risk.

GINA was passed to address concerns of individuals who might be reluctant to undergo genetic testing because the results, if disclosed to an employer, might be used in a discriminatory manner by employers. While it is premature to predict the probability of outcomes of this employment dispute, it reminds employers of their obligations to comply with GINA and other numerous other Federal and state laws concerning the management and use of health information in the workplace.

Related Links:

Hartford Courant
Woman claims genetic test led to firing at Stamford firm - StamfordAdvocate
Home WGGB abc40 News, Weather and Sports in Springfield Massachusetts

Monday, April 26, 2010

Proposed HITECH Regulations Out in May?

Buried in a part of today's Federal Register was the publication of the Department of Health and Human Services' regulatory agenda. The agenda presents a forecast of expected HHS rulemaking activities and suggests that in May of this year HHS will issue the long-awaited proposed rules to modify the HIPAA Privacy, Security, and Enforcement Rules as necessary to implement the privacy, security, and certain enforcement provisions of the HITECH Act (see our earlier blog posts).

The Department is also scheduled to issue a final rule in May of this year, addressing the certification standards and implementation criteria for electronic health record technology.

Thursday, April 15, 2010

Brokerage firm victim of elaborate extortion scheme - but also gets hit with a fine

Brokerage firm DA Davidson has agreed to pay a fine of $375,000 for failing to protect confidential client data from Latvian hackers who breached the company in 2007 in an online extortion scheme and the three have pleaded guilty in Montana.

The hackers used a SQL injection attack to obtain access to the company’s database on Dec. 25 and 26, 2007.

The Financial Industry Regulatory Authority, which announced the fine agreement on Monday, said although the attack activity was reflected in the brokerage’s server logs, administrators failed to examine those logs. The intruders obtained data on about 192,000 customers, according to the press release announcing the fine. (Previous reports indicated that more than 300,000 customer files were stolen). The data included customer account numbers, Social Security numbers, names, addresses, dates of birth and other private information.

The company discovered the breach only after receiving an extortion e-mail from one of the hackers on Jan. 16, 2008, which contained an attachment with the records of 20,000 customers as proof of the intrusion. DA Davidson contacted the Secret Service, and the subsequent investigation led to four suspects, three of whom are Latvian nationals, who were extradited from the Netherlands to face charges in Montana. In a statement released yesterday by the U.S. Attorney for Montana, the three Latvians pleaded guilty to receipt of extortion proceeds.

More: Wired Magazine
Three Plead Guilty in Plot to Extort DA Davidson - Financial Planning
The United States Department of Justice - United States Attorney's Office